upper waypoint

Mayor Breed Appoints 3 SFUSD Parents to Fill School Board Seats Vacated After Historic Recall

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

SF Mayor London Breed speaking to three women who have their right hands raised - on a high school football field.
San Francisco Mayor London Breed swears in (from left) Ann Hsu, Lainie Motamedi and Lisa Weissman-Ward as school board members, during a ceremony held on the football field of Galileo Academy of Science and Technology in San Francisco on March 11, 2022. (Guy Marzorati/KQED)

In a highly anticipated move, San Francisco Mayor London Breed on Friday appointed three new members to the San Francisco school board Friday, filling seats that were vacated after last month's landslide recall election.

At a ceremony at Galileo Academy of Science and Technology, Breed's alma mater, the mayor swore in Ann Hsu, Lainie Motamedi and Lisa Weissman-Ward, who will join the seven-member Board of Education. All three women are parents of students currently in the district and, like Breed, have called for greater fiscal responsibility.

"I'm so happy and I'm so proud that we have three amazing women who all have kids in our public school system, who all had a common theme of service," said Breed.

They replace Alison Collins, Gabriela López and Faauuga Moliga, who were ousted in a citywide recall vote on Feb. 15.

The three new commissioners will complete the remaining terms of their ousted predecessors, which end this year. All three face reelection campaigns in November, should they wish to keep their jobs.


Breed, who supported the recall, said her pick decisions came after what she described as weeks of meetings with parents and candidate interviews.

"I've really agonized over this decision," Breed said. "This is probably the hardest decision that I've ever had to make as mayor because it's about the future of our children."

The newly composed board will immediately face a complex set of issues and, potentially, a freshly energized parent base closely watching over their shoulders. Vincent Matthews, the district’s current superintendent, has said he is stepping down in June, so the new board will be charged with hiring his successor. Many parents who supported the recall said they wanted a more competent board to select the district’s next leader.

Hsu, the president of Galileo’s Parent Teacher Student Association, appeared in pro-recall advertisements and worked to register Asian American voters ahead of the special election. She also serves on the SFUSD Citizens' Bond Oversight Committee.

Related Coverage

"Being a first-generation immigrant, I also want to lift up the concerns and interests of the significant immigrant parents community in SFUSD," said Hsu, who lives in the Richmond District, and started her own business after emigrating from China.

Motamedi, from the city's Inner Sunset neighborhood, also has firsthand experience working with San Francisco's school district, where she helped to oversee school spending as a co-chair of the district's Public Education Enrichment Fund committee. She also served as a member of its Local Control and Accountability Plan task force

"My focus is to bring my experience and our collective experience to help all families and children in this city to get the support they need as we do the really, really challenging work to get our district back on track," she said.

Weissman-Ward, Breed’s third appointee, lives in the Mission District and is associate director of the Stanford Law School Immigrants’ Rights Clinic. Joining the board after years of contentious meetings that have at times erupted in bitter clashes among members, parents and students, she underscored the "importance of process."

"I’ve learned the value and importance of investing time into building rapport in order to better find common ground," she said. "Because if even at the outset we don’t agree, when we engage in a process that’s thoughtful, that’s transparent and that’s fair, we’ll be in a better position to move things forward."

The new superintendent and board will be tasked with long-standing issues, such as falling enrollment and racial gaps in academic achievement.

The district also is currently trying to solve problems with a new payroll operating system it began using in January. The transition to the new program has left some 200 educators either underpaid or without checks at all, and is causing problems for nearly 1,000 more, according to the United Educators of San Francisco, which is threatening a class-action lawsuit.

Also looming large are the final budget cuts that need approval to solve the district’s $125 million budget deficit. The outgoing board approved all but $3.8 million in cuts, refusing to lay off some 47 paraeducator positions. Instead, it asked the district to cut more management positions, and delayed delivery of its second interim budget report to the state — which it now must submit by March 22.

"As we fight for the schools our students deserve, we look forward to working with the 3 BOE appointees," the city's teachers union said in a statement. "Educators know our students deserve stable, staffed & funded schools to thrive and hope the BOE is prepared to work with educators, families & our communities to achieve this.”

Despite waning COVID-19 case levels in the city, the pandemic continues to pose challenges to how schools are run. Beginning on March 14, indoor masking will be optional for the district's middle and high school students, with elementary schools following suit on April 2.

However, some parents of children who are immunocompromised continue to speak out against the policy change, and the new board will certainly be managing how the district responds to any future variants. Frustration over the district’s decision to delay reopening schools during the pandemic was a major factor fueling the recall movement.

Perhaps the most politically fraught issue facing the new board members, however, is the admissions policy at the city’s elite Lowell High School. It remains to be seen whether the new board will bow to intense pressure from some parents and alumni to reinstate the school's merit-based admissions policy, or keep in place the new lottery system, which has helped significantly increase the number of Black and Latino students in this year's freshman class.

Despite arguments from the Lowell Alumni Association, the district has maintained that a return to admissions based on academic performance would violate state law.

In response to questionnaires from the supporters of the recall campaign, Hsu and Motamedi both said they would support reinstating Lowell's merit-based admissions process.

Weissman-Ward stopped short of saying where she stood on the issue.

"As a general matter I'll say I support equity, I support access and I support academically rigorous programs and I think as many people that can be a part of that is what I support," she said on Friday. "And we probably need to be lifting up and having more schools that are able to allow students to have these academically rigorous programs."


The next regularly scheduled board meeting is March 22, 2022.

lower waypoint
next waypoint
5 Takeaways from the 1st San Francisco Mayoral Candidate DebateWhat to Expect When Enrolling Your Child in Transitional KindergartenWhy Some Bay Area Counties May Lose Millions Over an Obscure Legal Fight With the State6 Months After People’s Park Closure, Many Former Residents and Supporters Struggle to AdjustHow Much Will It Cost You to Keep California's Last Nuclear Plant Running?California Poised to Slash Health Care Workforce Funding Amid Labor ShortagesHow The Closure Of Madera County's Only Hospital Has Impacted The CommunityA Berkeley Mother's Memoir Offers a Candid Commentary on the Crisis of MasculinityDoctors, Community Leaders Ramp Up Efforts to Halt Closure of East San José Trauma CenterWhy These Queer Pro-Palestinian Advocates Are Calling for a Boycott of SF Pride