upper waypoint

Is 'Green Spot' a Sign of More Trouble for Oroville Dam?

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

An inspection team views seepage at Oroville Dam's green spot in February 2011. The California Department of Water Resources says moisture in the area is due to rainfall and poses no threat to dam's integrity.  (California Department of Water Resources)

Updated 5:35 p.m. Friday


rom Day 1 of the Oroville spillway crisis in February, the California Department of Water Resources has never wavered in its declarations that, despite the disintegration of the massive concrete flood control outlet and a near-disaster caused by uncontrolled emergency reservoir flows down a rapidly eroding hillside, the stability of the massive dam itself was not and has never been threatened.

Despite those oft-repeated assurances, public questions about the dam's integrity have persisted -- in internet forums, in community meetings and, most recently, in a report released last week under the auspices of UC Berkeley's Center for Catastrophic Risk Management.

That's in part a reflection of public distrust of DWR after the spillway incident and in part a recognition that anything that seriously compromises the 770-foot-tall dam could endanger tens of thousands of lives, cripple a key element of California's water-supply network and put the state's entire economy at risk.

Specifically, the questions have focused on an extensive area of moisture on the left side of the dam's downstream face that's known, even to the Department of Water Resources, as "the green spot."


The spot, characterized by what state inspectors have termed "lush" vegetation during wet seasons that turns into dense thickets of dry weeds by late summer, is clearly visible on satellite images and measures about 700 feet long by 130 feet wide. That's roughly the size of two football fields.

A satellite image shows Oroville Dam's green spot on April 14, 2015. (Google Earth)

Last week's study, led by internationally known civil engineer and risk management analyst Robert Bea, included several subreports asking whether the moisture at the green spot is a sign that water is leaking through the dam and weakening its inner structure.

Publicly, DWR officials have tended to dismiss those concerns. In response to questions at community meetings in Oroville and Yuba City in May, for instance, the agency said the green area is due to rainfall, that it first appeared while the dam was under construction, and that it poses no risk to the dam.


ut outside public view, documents KQED obtained under the California Public Records Act show the Department of Water Resources has puzzled for years over the source of the seepage feeding the "green spot" and has been slow to act on a 2014 recommendation from independent experts to investigate the issue.

DWR's uncertainty is reflected in a series of dam inspections between February and July 2011 -- Northern California's last wet winter before the five-year drought -- that produced contradictory conclusions about the issue and whether it was a chronic condition or something that appeared only seasonally.

On Feb. 2, 2011, a DWR inspection party hiked to the green spot -- about 200 vertical feet below the top of the massive structure -- and found extensive moisture.

"The cause of the seepage has yet to be determined," wrote Bill Pennington of DWR's Division of Safety of Dams (DSOD).

An April 2014 inspection photograph of the Oroville Dam green spot. State officials say moisture has been observed in this area of the dam's downstream face since before Lake Oroville filled in the late 1960s, but they've never determined the source. (California Department of Water Resources)

One possibility, he said, was rainwater may have collected -- or become "perched," in engineering parlance -- within the dam's embankment. Another possible source: an area of seepage that had been noted in the dam's abutment during construction in the 1960s.

Pennington suggested that the area should be monitored and "unexpected changes should be reported to DSOD." In a field notebook, Pennington wrote that Paul Dunlap of DWR's Dam Safety Branch was "thinking of mapping the area."

After a May 2011 inspection visit, Pennington wrote that "the long-established wet area at mid-slope on the left end of the dam remains active" and recommended continued monitoring.

In July 2011, with the lake level unseasonably high -- less than 2 feet below the edge of the dam's emergency weir -- DWR's Paul Dunlap returned to check out the green spot. He found it had "essentially dried up."

"The drying out of the green spot (especially under high reservoir conditions) provides further evidence that the green spot phenomena on the dam is associated with precipitation or abutment seasonal spring activity and not seepage through the dam," Dunlap wrote in a report on his findings.

An image from a 2013 Oroville Dam inspection report noting the effects of moisture from the dam's "green spot." (California Department of Water Resources)


hose periodic observations continued -- sometimes the green spot was wet, sometimes dry -- along with Pennington's repeated recommendation that dam managers figure out how to monitor the area "so that year to year changes can be recorded."

In August 2014, an independent board met to perform the dam's five-year federal safety review. The board's recommendations, released in December, called on DWR officials to investigate the green spot and try to determine whether it posed a threat to the dam.

"This issue has a high historical profile that needs to be conclusively addressed," the consultants commented in one section of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's 2014 Part 12D report.

The board said that while much of the dam's behavior was understood, "one issue that seems to not have been addressed by previous stability analyses is that associated with the green spot on the downstream face of the dam."

The consultants' report noted that the final construction report for the dam, which went into service in 1968, indicated that the green spot area was observed even before Lake Oroville began rising behind the structure.

"The green spot is believed to be associated with pre-existing natural springs in the downstream left abutment area of the dam foundation," the Part 12D report says. The concentration of moisture, the document speculates, could be due to the composition of the rock and earth used to build the dam's downstream embankment. The fill, which may contain excessive volumes of very fine, dense material, "may prevent free drainage of flows from those underlying springs."

The four consultants said that although there was no evidence of movement or instability in the green spot area, they recommended the Department of Water Resources investigate to see whether the persistent moisture could pose a risk to the dam, especially in the event an earthquake occurred during a period of particularly wet conditions.


n response, the Department of Water Resources has told the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission it intends to answer questions raised in the 2014 safety board report by September 2018.

The department last year got approval to bore a hole as deep as 150 feet in the dam's left abutment, adjacent to the green spot area. The drilling was to pursue a separate issue raised by the safety board -- the seismic vulnerability of Oroville Dam and nearby facilities. As part of that work, DWR told FERC, it planned to install an instrument for "monitoring groundwater levels in proximity (to) the historic 'green spot' within the dam embankment. Data collected may provide beneficial in understanding the origin of seepage within the left abutment."

After a wave of questions raised by the UC Berkeley Center for Catastrophic Risk Management report issued last week, DWR says it's preparing a preliminary report on the green spot as well as a longer-term study of the issue. The report is due out next week, DWR spokeswoman Erin Mellon said Friday.

In response to questions about DWR's response to the safety board recommendations or suggestions for monitoring made in the department's own inspection reports, Mellon said regular monitoring was ongoing and that "to date, no issues of concern have been noted."

Bea, the leader of the UC Berkeley study, says that DWR has been complacent in its response to a host of issues related to the dam, including the green spot.

"I think these people are looking at these pieces of evidence and using their logic, 'Well, this dam's been here for 50 years. We've seen these wet spots before, and it's performed satisfactorily,' " Bea said. "What they're then concluding is that as you move forward into the future it will continue to perform satisfactorily. That conclusion is premised on a belief there won't be any changes as you move into the future."

Bea says that posture is similar to the one the department took to the dam's spillway. The imposing concrete structure had undergone several rounds of extensive repairs before it failed in February. Despite that history of recurring problems, there's no evidence that the department considered the possibility that the spillway might need to be rebuilt, and DWR inspections through last August consistently declared the structure fit for continued use.

"They kept thinking (that despite) these early warning signs -- 'Yeah, they're unusual, we've got to put concrete patches on those cracks. And yeah, there are voids under the concrete that we'll fill with concrete' -- it's going to remain stable," Bea said. "That proved to be disastrously wrong."

lower waypoint
next waypoint
Newsom Says California Water Tunnel Will Cost $20 Billion. Officials and Experts Say It's Worth ItDavid DePape Sentenced to 30 Years in Federal Prison for Attack on Nancy Pelosi's HusbandProsecutors to Push for Terrorism Enhancement in Sentencing of David DePape, Who Bludgeoned Paul Pelosi in 2022Sonoma State University's Deal With Student Protesters in Limbo After President's RemovalUC Santa Cruz Academic Workers to Strike Over University's Treatment of Pro-Palestinian ProtestersHighway 1 to Big Sur Has Reopened — What to Know About Visiting from the Bay AreaAt the California GOP Convention, Optimism About NovemberDutch Research Team Recounts the Long-Term Effects of StarvationCalifornia Wants Cities to Plan For More Housing. Cities Say the Rules Are UnclearA Wedding Behind the Walls of San Quentin