Major support for MindShift comes from
Outschool Logo

Good Read: Ed Tech Should Be More Like Graphing Calculators, Less Like iPads

Save ArticleSave Article

Failed to save article

Please try again

This article is more than 9 years old.

In his Atlantic article, Phil Nichols argues that many of the flashy digital tools in classrooms today do a good job of  aiding formal teaching, but not necessarily promoting student discovery.  He argues education technology should look more like a programmable calculator, offering the intrepid student an easy language with which to code and pursue independent learning. On an iPad a student can only experiment within the world of an app or program created by someone else. It's much harder to develop something from scratch. Nicols writes:

"Texas Instruments unwittingly embedded a flexible programming environment into a ubiquitous technology accessible to (and even required of) most high school students. These devices not only fulfill their conventional role as tools for calculation but can also support more subversive uses. The TI-83 and its kindred are Trojan Horses, sneaking in subversive education under the auspices of convention."

Last year, while cleaning out the basement of my childhood home, I discovered a plastic storage bin marked "Calcusoft." Inside were piles of notebooks filled with sketches, storyboards, and lines of code, and buried beneath it all, a TI-83 Plus graphing calculator.

Read more at: