California Pulls National Guard Troops from Trump's Border Effort to Tackle Fire Protection

Embers fly as the Camp Fire tears through Paradise on Nov. 8, 2018. (JOSH EDELSON/AFP/Getty Images)

California is calling in the National Guard in April to help protect communities from devastating fires like the one that largely destroyed the town of Paradise last fall.

Coverage of the Camp Fire

The state is pulling the troops away from President Trump's border protection efforts and devoting them to fire protection, another area where Trump has been critical of California's Democratic officials — repeatedly threatening to cut off federal disaster funding.

Starting next week, 110 California National Guard troops will receive 11 days of training in using shovels, rakes and chainsaws to help thin trees and brush, said Mike Mohler, a spokesman for the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection.

The troops will be divided into five teams that will travel around the state starting in April to work on forest management projects, mainly clearing or reducing trees and vegetation in an effort to deprive flames of fuel.


"They will be boots on the ground doing fuels projects alongside Cal Fire crews," Mohler said. "We've had them out for flood fighting, several different operations, but this would be the first time their mission would be fuels thinning and forest management."

They have helped fight fires before, however.

Former Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger was the first in recent decades to deploy California National Guard troops as firefighters, dispatching them on July 4, 2008, after lightning storms sparked hundreds of fires, Guard Lt. Col. Jonathan Shiroma said.

While many of the troops are being reassigned from the border this time, the Guard also is asking other service members if they want to participate, Shiroma said.

The training is similar for firefighting and fire protection. Mohler said the troops also will receive some training in forest management, "so they're not just out there cutting brush" but understand why they're doing what they're doing.

For instance, firefighting crews generally cut fire lines down to mineral earth during active wildfires, while fuels-management crews often do less intensive thinning of trees and chaparral to slow advancing flames.

Such preventive treatment often involves creating fuel breaks, which can range from stripping away all woody vegetation on wide strips of land to thinning larger trees and removing shorter trees, brush and debris to discourage fires from climbing into treetops and jumping from tree to tree.

Coverage of the North Bay fires

Critics say the work damages forests and can be useless against wind-driven fires, like the one that jumped a river to rain embers on the Sierra Nevada foothills community of Paradise last year, killing 85 people in and around the Northern California city of 27,000 people.

"Cal Fire is taking the Trump approach, logging the forest and weakening critical environmental protections, and that's the exact opposite of what we need to be doing," said Shaye Wolf, a scientist at the Center for Biological Diversity.

Wolf said a better approach is to make homes more fire-resistant while pruning vegetation immediately surrounding the structures.

In March, Cal Fire listed 35 fuel-reduction projects it wants to start immediately, covering more than 140 square miles — double the acreage in previous years. But state officials estimate 23,438 square miles of forestland need thinning or other restoration.

"It's not a problem that's going to get fixed overnight," Mohler said.

Such thinning operations are getting more attention in recent years, with the U.S. Forest Service estimating last month that 18 million trees died in California over the last year.

The agency estimated that more than 147 million trees have died across nearly 15,625 square miles during a drought that began in 2010, while about 1.5 million dead trees have been cut down.

Moreover, investigations have often blamed recent wildfires on utilities not doing a good enough job of clearing vegetation around power lines and equipment. Democratic state Sen. Bill Dodd of Napa has proposed legislation that would require Cal Fire to tell utilities which trees and brush to remove and then inspect the work.

Aside from Guard troops, Cal Fire also is creating 10 civilian fuels management crews this year. The 10-member crews could help with initial fire suppression if need be but will primarily reduce fuels, Mohler said.

"It's going to be a pretty amazing sight to see as these crews get out there on the ground," he said. "There's hundreds of, unfortunately, Paradises cross the state, (so) the public needs to understand this."