upper waypoint

Towing Reform: New Bill Seeks to Repeal ‘Poverty Tows’

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

San Francisco is home to some of the nation's highest rents, but also some of the most expensive tows. (Kip Gebhardt/KQED)

For many Californians, having a car towed is not only a costly inconvenience but can mean losing access to a job, education, medical care or even shelter, according to a new report by a coalition of civil rights attorneys.

Towing in California

The report, “Towed Into Debt,” found that the top three reasons for towing — unpaid parking tickets, expired car registration or parking in a legal spot for more than 72 hours — disproportionately impacted low-income Californians, causing many of them to permanently lose their vehicle. The report, which included data on city-ordered towing practices across California, was released Monday.

San Francisco Assemblyman David Chiu is taking action on these findings: He introduced Assembly Bill 516 on Monday. If passed, the bill would repeal the three towing policies he and advocates say are “poverty tows.”

“If you don't have the money to pay your parking tickets or to update your registration, the idea that the state should be able to deprive you of the most valuable economic asset you have, which will cause you to lose your job, your livelihood or even your only shelter, doesn't make any sense to me,” he said in announcing the legislation at a San Francisco tow lot.

The quickly escalating costs of having a vehicle impounded usually mean poor Californians can’t afford to get their cars back. Including original tickets, accrued fines and charges for towing and impounding, it would now cost Sean Kayode more than $21,000 to get his car back.
The escalating costs of having a vehicle impounded usually mean poor Californians can’t afford to get their cars back. Including original tickets, accrued fines and charges for towing and impounding. (John Moore/Getty Images)

According to the report, vehicles impounded for the three offenses are up to six times more likely to be sold by towing companies than the average towed car. Cars that aren’t retrieved within 30 days are put up for auction in lien sales to offset the debt.


Why is Towing So Expensive in San Francisco?

“More courts are realizing that punishing people just because they can’t afford to pay is not in line with our constitutional principles,” said Elisa Della-Piana, legal director of Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay, one of the contributors to the report. “The 4th Amendment prohibits unreasonable seizures.”

Before retrieving a car impounded by the city, the owner has to pay off all parking tickets and any registration fees. The report says that getting a car back can cost an average of $1,100.

That’s what happened to Mary Lovelace, a former home improvement specialist: The city of San Francisco towed her car after they booted it for not paying parking tickets. Unable to drive to her clients, she said she couldn’t afford the fees to retrieve her car.

“I was evicted because I couldn't pay the rent,” said Lovelace.

Mary Lovelace is one of many Californians who have permanentley lost their car due to a city ordered tow,
Mary Lovelace could not afford to pay her parking tickets and eventually lost her vehicle after a city-ordered tow. (Marisol Medina-Cadena/KQED) (Marisol Medina-Cadena/KQED)

She never got her car back and ended up declaring bankruptcy. She remains without a car and unable to work. Lovelace, who spoke alongside Assemblyman Chiu, said she hopes the bill passes so it can prevent others from being in a situation like her.

City-ordered tows also drain money from local governments since low income residents are less likely to retrieve their cars from lots, the report found. And, revenue from a lien sale is much less than the cost to store and tow the vehicle, meaning municipalities and towing companies are unlikely to fully collect their debts.

The California Tow Truck Association declined to comment to KQED about the new legislation.

lower waypoint
next waypoint
Confrontation at UC Berkeley Law School Dean's Home Highlights Campus TensionsOakland Officials to Proceed With Controversial Move to Rename AirportWho Is Responsible For One of the Largest Internet Hacks Ever?Eucalyptus: How California's Most Hated Tree Took RootDespite Warnings, People Are Still Dying While Being Held Face Down By PoliceMeet the Dance and Music Teachers Bringing Peruvian Culture to the BayCalifornia's Black Lawmakers are Advancing Different Sets of Reparations BillsSo You Want to Be a DJ?Public School Choice Is Possible by Law, but Not Many Districts Offer ItInside or Out of Government, Jessica Bartholow Is an Advocate for Economic Equity