upper waypoint

District 3 Candidates Court Chinatown Vote

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

David Lee directs the Chinese American Voters Education Committee. (Mina Kim/KQED)

The contest with the biggest implications for San Francisco city government this November is the race for supervisor in District 3. It will determine whether the Board of Supervisors keeps its moderate majority that's friendly to Mayor Ed Lee or shifts the power balance to the progressives. The mayor's pick -- incumbent Julie Christensen -- is being challenged by former supervisor Aaron Peskin.  Longtime Chinatown resident Wilma Pang completes the field.

District 3 includes Telegraph Hill, North Beach and Chinatown. When I meet David Lee at Chinatown’s Portsmouth Square, he tells me that Chinatown residents will decide the election and with it the city’s political future. Lee is a lecturer of political science at San Francisco State University and heads up the nonpartisan Chinese American Voters Education Committee, which is dedicated to voter registration. In 2012, he himself ran for supervisor in District 1 but did not win.

“Chinatown has the largest percentage of decline-to-state voters and new voters in the district," Lee says. “They’re the classic up-for-grabs voters.”

Small wonder why campaign signs blanket storefronts around Portsmouth Square. Signs supporting Aaron Peskin outnumber those supporting Julie Christensen.

“I certainly see Peskin’s message of housing affordability and housing rights resonating with tenants here,” Lee said. “Still, the mayor enjoys strong support in the Chinese-American community."


As if on cue, we run into Calvin Louie, an accountant who sits on the board of the Chinese American Democratic Club.

"I’m supporting Julie Christensen,” Louie says. “The mayor’s appointee.”

Aaron Peskin signs blanket storefronts in San Francisco's Chinatown.
Aaron Peskin signs blanket storefronts in San Francisco's Chinatown. (Mina Kim/KQED)

Louie says he believes Christensen will help small businesses. He says the closure of the venerable Empress of China restaurant last year has stirred anxiety among small business owners like him.

Christensen has also tried to align herself with long-shot supervisorial candidate Wilma Pang. She’s taken out ads in Chinese newspaper asking voters to choose both of them.

“Keep in mind that with ranked-choice voting, you can choose up to three candidates,” Lee says. “Some Chinese-Americans through an affinity vote may vote for Wilma, but there’s also a second choice and a third choice, and Christensen and Peskin have been fighting hard for that spot.”

Mailers, television and newspaper ads have been bombarding voters in Chinatown. Lee says the District 3 contest could go down as the most expensive supervisor race in San Francisco history.

“Upwards of $2 million in independent expenditure funds have come into the district,” Lee says.

Recent figures show the Christensen and Peskin campaigns themselves have spent $378,000 and $436,000 respectively.

Lee says every vote will count in this off-year election because there will be so few of them to go around.

Ads taken out by Julie Christensen.
Ad taken out by Julie Christensen. (San Francisco Ethics Commission )

“You look at the number of ballots that have been cast so far, and there are very few voters paying attention,” Lee says. “That means the voters who are paying attention will get to decide”

But voters in Chinatown are engaged, according to an analysis of vote-by-mail ballots by the Chinese American Voters Education Committee. With more than 6,000 ballots cast by the district so far, 38 percent are from Chinese-Americans. Lee says that’s more than their roughly 20 percent share of the district population.

“It is a community of immigrants that is really just starting to feel its political oats,” Lee says. “It’s ironic because it comes at a time when gentrification threatens the viability of this community.”

lower waypoint
next waypoint
Newsom Says California Water Tunnel Will Cost $20 Billion. Officials and Experts Say It's Worth ItHighway 1 to Big Sur Has Reopened — What to Know About Visiting from the Bay AreaDavid DePape Sentenced to 30 Years in Federal Prison for Attack on Nancy Pelosi's HusbandSonoma State University's Deal With Student Protesters in Limbo After President's RemovalWhen BART Was Built, People — and Houses — Had to GoCalifornia's Nuumu People Claim LA Stole Their Water, Now They're Fighting for Its ReturnCalifornia Forever Says 12 Start-Ups Will Open Workplaces in Its New CityProsecutors to Push for Terrorism Enhancement in Sentencing of David DePape, Who Bludgeoned Paul Pelosi in 2022'A Chance to Harmonize' Tells the Story of the U.S. Music UnitSan Francisco Homelessness Up 7% Despite Decline in Street Camping