Power from solar farms like this one in Fresno drops off at sunset, just as Californians need the most energy. Terry O'Rourke/NREL
Power from solar farms like this one in Fresno drops off at sunset, just as Californians need the most energy. (Terry O'Rourke/NREL)

Too Much Solar in California? Not If You Bottle It

Too Much Solar in California? Not If You Bottle It

Save ArticleSave Article

Failed to save article

Please try again

This article is more than 6 years old.

The cost of solar power has plummeted in recent years, which has led to a renewable energy boom in California.

But there’s a big hang-up: solar energy doesn’t provide a 24-hour supply. When the sun sets, the power from solar farms drops off, just as California needs it most.

That’s sparked new interest in technology that stores electricity. And the energy storage technology race is going far beyond your typical battery.

Solar Peaking

“Pretty much everyday, we hit peak output,” says Michael Wheeler, a vice president at Recurrent Energy in San Francisco, looking at a screen showing the solar farms his company manages.


But earlier this spring, something happened that, at first, doesn’t seem to make sense.

It was the middle of the day, when one of the solar farms was cranking out electricity, and his company got a message.

“The grid operator is telling us they don’t need all of it,” Wheeler says.

There was too much electricity on the grid. The electric grid managers were telling solar farms to shut down.

“The project went from almost peak output to zero for about two hours,” he says.

This happens on sunny, spring days when there is plenty of solar power but Californians aren’t using a lot of air conditioning yet, so demand for power is low.

The solar and wind power comes in on top of what natural gas power plants are generating. Because renewable energy production goes up and down with passing clouds and wind conditions, grid operators say they need the continuous supply from natural gas to make up for those fluctuations.

PG&E's battery in San Jose can store more than six hours of energy.
PG&E's battery in San Jose can store more than six hours of energy. (PG&E)

Shutting down natural gas would leave the power supply less stable. Many gas plants can take between four and eight hours to restart, once they’re turned off.

As more solar farms come online, the pressure to shut them down on mild, sunny days is only expected to become greater. California plans to get 50 percent of its electricity from renewable sources by 2030.

“We’ve built these solar projects and to the extent that we have to turn them off more and more often, it doesn’t make a lot of sense,” Wheeler says. “It would be a lot better to find uses for that electricity.”

Shifting Solar

California’s grid operators have proposed linking the state’s grid to other Western states, so the excess solar energy could be shared.

Another solution is to store the solar energy, because there’s an obvious need for power in the evening, right as the sun goes down.

“Everybody comes home from work and they turn on their lights and that uses a lot of power,” says Shayle Kann who analyzes renewable energy at Greentech Media in Boston.

California’s electricity demand peaks in the evening. Storing solar power for just a few hours would allow solar farms to help meet that peak.

“It makes that solar energy dispatchable,” he says. “In other words, you can control when it goes into the grid.”

Listen to the Story:

Since California regulators don’t want to see solar farms turn off, they’re requiring utilities to build energy storage on the grid. All together, Pacific Gas & Electric, Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric must install 1.3 gigawatts of energy storage by 2020, which is about the same as a couple power plants.

That mandate is the first of its kind in the country. So far, batteries have been the dominant technology.

“Batteries in consumer electronics—you’re used to your Duracell batteries and things—we’ve had those for a very long time,” says Kann. “What’s new is deploying that on a large scale for the grid.”

There are a handful of large banks of batteries on the grid already, some the size of a semi-truck, which can store electricity for several hours.

Bottling Electricity

Batteries are coming down in cost dramatically, but they’re still relatively expensive compared to other sources of power.

That’s launched start-up companies looking for a different way to store energy.

“So what you’re looking at, really, is best described as a giant scuba tank,” says Steve Crane, pointing to a 25-foot tank in the warehouse of his company, LightSail Energy in Berkeley, California.

Steve Crane of LightSail Energy at their headquarters in Berkeley.
Steve Crane of LightSail Energy at their headquarters in Berkeley. (Lauren Sommer/KQED)

A scuba tank is the inspiration for his technology, which compresses air.

“The electrical energy is hard to hold on to,” says Crane. “Compressed air is relatively easy to store for hours or even days.”

Here’s how it works: when there’s extra electricity, Crane turns on a giant air pump. It fills the tank, compressing the air by 200 times.

Then when electricity is needed, the air is released to drive an electric generator. The hard part has been dealing with all the heat this makes; Crane’s technology uses water to capture some of the heat.

“Any air compressor that you use, even a bicycle pump, creates heat,” says Crane. “A bicycle pump will feel warm after you’ve used it for a while.”

The idea of storing energy by compressing air isn't new, but other projects have stored the air in large underground caverns.

By using tanks, LightSail's technology would be more modular. It's still in the early stages, with the company working on its first pilot projects. But Crane hopes it will have an edge over batteries, because it’s likely going to be cheaper and it lasts longer.

“If you have a laptop or cell phone," he says, "you know that after two to three years, you start to see significant deterioration."

Crane says interest has sky-rocketed for energy storage technology like his and other other non-battery approaches, such as ice, molten salt or mechanical machines called flywheels.

“Nobody had ever heard of energy storage when I got into this field six or seven years ago,” he says. “Now it’s something that the governor of California talks about. However, the funding that is available for new technology in this area is pretty much zero.”

Research and development can take years and venture capital firms like to see faster results.


But if California is to meet its ambitious renewable energy goals, energy storage technology will have to catch up.