With Residential Retrofit Scheme, Oakland Enters Next Phase of Quakeproofing

Oakland apartment building
Oakland gains character as well as affordable housing from its stock of small and mid-sized apartment buildings. A city plan is being prepared to strengthen this crucial part of the city's fabric against earthquake damage. (Andrew Alden photos)

When the Bay Area's next big earthquake strikes, forecasts say that more than 150,000 housing units will be permanently lost and their residents made homeless—as things stand now. The majority of those earthquake refugees will come from one class of structure: small wood-framed apartment buildings with soft stories. Cities are now targeting these weak points in the urban fabric. Oakland, the Bay Area city with the greatest length of major fault lines in its borders, is joining Berkeley and San Francisco with a major strengthening program for soft-story apartments.

It takes time to prepare a region against deadly earthquakes. A million things need attention, and most of them involve fixing structures that weren't built with earthquakes in mind. In the 25 years since the Loma Prieta quake, Bay Area agencies have taken care of the big-ticket items. Caltrans has beefed up the big bridges and all the freeway overpasses. BART has strengthened its tracks and stations. The water agencies have fixed their largest mains wherever they cross a major fault line. The power and gas systems are much more robust today.

Once a city's lifelines are able to survive an earthquake, the next step is to see that residents can quickly resume their lives—with homes, schools and jobs. Schools are seismically strong, thanks to the Field Act of 1933. Modern business buildings meet strong codes and should be quickly repairable. Streets are straightforward to fix. Living places are the weakest link, and Oakland has been working on a program for several years to retrofit vulnerable residences.

The biggest payoff is in fixing soft-story apartments—buildings with ground floors occupied by parking spaces or retail shops. When one of these building slumps, everyone in it is displaced, the building is ruined and its neighboring properties are jeopardized. The Loma Prieta earthquake in 1989 brought down many of these in the Marina district of San Francisco, and in Oakland some 1300 residence units of this type were lost or severely damaged—and in those cities that did not count as a major quake.

It pays in many ways to preserve them instead. Oakland's city administrator, Henry Gardner, made a succinct case for a retrofit program in a recent memo to the City Council:

Retrofitting soft-story apartment buildings will likely save lives, minimize injuries and help keep people in their homes after a major disaster. Renters can avoid personal losses, costs associated with relocating, and inflated rental prices. In particular, retrofitting soft-story apartment buildings will protect the most vulnerable, the same people most at risk of being displaced after a disaster. Building owners can avoid the cost of demolishing and rebuilding, and avoid revenue loss while rebuilding occurs. The public sector can avoid the cost of emergency services for disaster housing, and the loss of tax revenue from rental property owners. Additionally, retrofitting soft-story apartment buildings aligns with Oakland's sustainability goals by reducing the City's post-earthquake carbon footprint.

Classic Oakland apartment building
Detail of small apartment building overlooking Lake Merritt

It also must be said that these buildings are an important part of Oakland's heritage and character. Many of them were built in the 1920s, and they dominate cherished neighborhoods all around Lake Merritt as well as the Dimond, Laurel and East Lake.

Oakland soft-story inventory map
Portion of Oakland's map of soft-story apartment buildings. Green shades refer to average household income. The volunteer coders of the Open Oakland nonprofit have put together SoftStory, an interactive map showing each of these residential buildings along with its status—evaluated, not yet evaluated, or exempt. (City of Oakland)

Oakland started its focus on soft-story apartments in 2008 with a preliminary survey that mapped 1400 of these buildings, then a 2009 ordinance requiring their owners to assess their structures. Now it's ready to move ahead with a formal Soft Story Retrofit Program that will be presented to the City Council in a few months. Its basic elements are becoming clear, but the details are fluid. Building owners and residents will share the cost of retrofits, and a long menu of possible incentives will be considered. There is seed money available. (More details are given in Gardner's memo.)

Sponsored

The first of several hearings on the proposal will be held tonight from 5:30 to 7 pm at Oakland City Hall in Hearing Room 1. (City Hall, I should point out, is itself a monument to retrofitting.) The Chief Resilience Officer of Oakland, Victoria Salinas, will speak and her San Francisco counterpart, Patrick Otellini, will share his city's experience with its retrofit ordinance.

More reading:

Association of Bay Area Governments page on Oakland Soft-Story Buildings

Berkeley's Soft-Story Retrofit Program

Oakland Soft-Story Seismic Screening page

Sponsored

San Francisco: "Survival of the Retrofittest" by Patrick Otellini

Volume
KQED Live
Live Stream
Log In ToPledge-Free Stream
LATEST NEWSCAST
KQED
NPR
Live Stream information currently unavailable.
Share
LATEST NEWSCAST
KQED
NPR
KQED Live

Live Stream

Live Stream information currently unavailable.