upper waypoint

Stockton Police: Officers Killed Hostage in Bank Robbery

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

Screen capture from KTVU video showing vehicle that carried Stockton bank robbery suspects and hostages during a chase and gun battle with police.
Screen capture from KTVU video showing vehicle that carried Stockton bank robbery suspects and hostages during a chase and gunbattle with police.

The hostage who died during a bank robbery and chase in Stockton last month was killed by police, not the suspects, authorities said Monday.

The results of a preliminary ballistics report show that Stockton police fired the bullet or bullets that killed 41-year-old Misty Holt-Singh, Stockton Police Chief Eric Jones said.

Holt-Singh was found dead at the end of last month's bank robbery and chase, which included a running gunbattle between the three suspects and police before a final shootout.

Police have said the sole surviving suspect, 19-year-old Jaime Ramos, used Holt-Singh as a human shield.

Holt-Singh was among three women the suspects took hostage during the July 16 bank robbery. Holt-Singh was a customer whose 12-year-old daughter was waiting outside in the car. The other two women were bank employees.

Sponsored

A police pursuit and shootout followed when the robbers armed with three handguns and an AK-47 fled with the hostages in an SUV owned by one of the employees. The two bank employees survived the ordeal by either jumping or getting thrown from the SUV as it sped through town during the hourlong chase. Several patrol cars and up to a dozen homes were struck by gunfire as police and the suspects exchanged fire.

Two of the suspects, identified by police as Alex Gregory Martinez, 27, and Gilbert Renteria Jr., 30, and Holt-Singh were found dead at the end of a final gunbattle. Jaime Ramos has been charged with murder.

Earlier this month, an attorney for Holt-Singh's family filed public records requests with the Stockton Police Department and several other law enforcement agencies for evidence related to the shooting.

The Stockton Record reported:

Citing the California Public Records Act, [attorney Greg] Bentley requested information such as incident reports, records of 911 calls and radio calls, photographs, videos and other evidence documenting the incident as well as protocols for kidnappings, pursuits and the use of deadly force.

"We know a fundamental tenet of law enforcement is protection, and within that there are fundamental principles called 'Priority of Life,' " Bentley said, apparently alluding to standards outlined by the National Tactical Officers Association. "The first priority in all circumstances is: No. 1 hostages, No. 2 bystanders, No. 3 police and No. 4 suspects.

"We know Misty was a hostage inside a vehicle and she was tragically taken, and so we want to see whether or not proper protocol was followed, whether proper systems and protocol were in place, and whether there was proper training and execution. We're asking the department to provide us with the policies, procedures and guidelines that are in place as well as information regarding whether or not the protocol in place was followed or if, perhaps, there were mistakes or a breakdown in communication that occurred, resulting in the tragic death of an innocent hostage."

Investigators say they have linked Martinez to a robbery on Jan. 31 at the same bank branch through surveillance video, witness statements and comparable circumstances.

Police also say they have recovered a dark Buick sedan seen on video dropping off the suspects at the bank. The car had no license plates and had been abandoned in a neighborhood about a 10-minute drive from the bank. Police have been trying to identify the driver.

This post is based on reporting from the Associated Press and Stockton Record.

lower waypoint
next waypoint
Pro-Palestinian Protests Sweep Bay Area College Campuses Amid Surging National MovementState Court Upholds Alameda County Tax Measure Yielding Hundreds of Millions for Child CareYouth Takeover: Parents (and Teachers) Just Don't UnderstandSan José Adding Hundreds of License Plate Readers Amid Privacy and Efficacy ConcernsCalifornia Law Letting Property Owners Split Lots to Build New Homes Is 'Unconstitutional,' Judge RulesViolence Escalates in Sudan as Civil War Enters Second YearSF Emergency Dispatchers Struggle to Respond Amid Outdated Systems, Severe UnderstaffingLess Than 1% of Santa Clara County Contracts Go to Black and Latino Businesses, Study ShowsHow the Supreme Court Case on Homelessness Could Affect the BayCalifornia Moves to Create a 'Sanctuary' for Arizona Women Seeking Abortions