upper waypoint

Next Santa Clara County Sheriff Will Face Jail's Broken Mental Health Care System

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

The four leading candidates for Santa Clara County Sheriff are (from left) Bob Jonsen, Sean Allen, Christine Nagaye and Kevin Jensen. (Courtesy of the campaign of Bob Jonsen/the campaign of Sean Allen/Jillian Cocklin/the campaign of Kevin Jensen)

Santa Clara County Sheriff Laurie Smith is retiring next year amid civil grand jury hearings, allegations of bribery and misconduct and investigations into jail abuse cases. Four candidates are leading in the race to replace her in the primary election on June 7 and are making promises to increase mental health care resources and increase transparency under a new administration. But residents of the county are skeptical about how much can actually be accomplished by a single sheriff.

Falling through the system of care's cracks

Jacob Wakeland, a resident of Santa Clara County, wants better access to comprehensive mental health care. In February 2021, he moved into a home in San José shared with roommates he didn’t know. Soon after moving in, Wakeland started noticing symptoms in one particular roommate, who is remaining unnamed in this story for privacy reasons.

“Initially after moving in, he was helpful and personable,” Wakeland said. “But he had a lot of nervous tics, which a lot of people have, but they were adding up a lot.”

His roommate eventually told Wakeland he had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder, but was refusing to get treatment. As months wore on, Wakeland noticed his roommate stayed awake most nights and starved himself, even refusing offers of food. Growing increasingly concerned, Wakeland called Mobile Crisis Teams, one of the county’s behavioral health care resources.

“The Mobile Crisis Team came out, and there were some counselors there, and they mentioned to me that he has to be [at] this [level] of severity where he’s not able to eat, like close to death,” Wakeland said.


Because his roommate was not at immediate risk of harming himself or others, the crisis team couldn’t force him into treatment. Then one day the roommate attacked Wakeland, and was arrested and sent to jail.

“There’s this series of events [where] you could clearly see all these cracks in the system of help that he fell through — every single one. And now they’re charging him with all these crimes that he didn’t even need to be in a position to commit,” Wakeland said.

County under pressure to expand resources

Like many other sheriff’s departments in California, Santa Clara County’s has come under fire for its lack of mental health resources, and its treatment of people who are mentally ill and incarcerated in county jails. Over the past six years, the county has settled at least three multimillion-dollar cases over incidents that left mentally ill incarcerated people permanently disabled, or dead: In 2015, three sheriff’s deputies fatally beat Michael Tyree, a 31-year-old man who had bipolar disorder.

And after the county paid a $10 million settlement to the family of Andrew Hogan, a formerly incarcerated man who became quadriplegic after suffering injuries sustained while under the sheriff’s supervision, calls for more comprehensive mental health care grew louder. Some county officials have suggested building a mental health care facility outside the jails, to treat individuals who may need medication or psychiatric care otherwise inaccessible to them.

The four leading contenders in the sheriff's race all speak to the need for better mental health resources. Bob Jonsen is promising to strengthen programs such as the one he founded as Palo Alto police chief that pairs police officers with a licensed mental health professional to get help for people in crisis. The other three candidates — Christine Nagaye, Kevin Jensen and Sean Allen — have all proposed building a new mental health facility, citing abandoned buildings and hospital grounds as potential locations.

“I think it’s a good cause, but for a candidate to say simply, this is what I’m going to do, meaning provide this facility, it’s mission impossible,” said LaDoris Hazzard Cordell, a former Santa Clara County Superior Court judge and the former independent police auditor for the City of San José. “It has to be done with the support of a board of supervisors who can allocate the funding for such a major project.”

Last year, County Supervisor Susan Ellenberg proposed diverting money and resources that were set aside to build a new jail and instead build a mental health care facility under the control of the county’s behavioral health services. But supervisors ultimately voted to build the new jail and deferred action on a behavioral health care facility into the vague future.

“How realistic is it that this can be addressed now and something can happen in our lifetimes?” asked Cordell. “It’s very realistic, in my view. It’s all about leadership.”

Last year, the office of California Attorney General Rob Bonta launched a civil rights investigation into how mentally ill people are treated in Santa Clara County jails managed by the sheriff’s department.

“There certainly has been a lot in Santa Clara County focusing on the sheriff’s office,” said Michael Gennaco, the project manager for the Office of Correction and Law Enforcement Monitoring (OCLEM).

Since its formation in 2018, OCLEM has asked the sheriff’s office to turn over documentation from internal investigations or disciplinary actions against certain officers, and has met with resistance. While Gennaco says he hopes the next sheriff will be more transparent, he acknowledges the position is an independently elected one, answerable to the voters.

“There is a different dynamic about sheriffs in California in that there are no real internal controls over how they do their work,” he said. “Santa Clara is an example of how that independence can get in the way of oversight.”

The primary election is on June 7.

lower waypoint
next waypoint
Newsom Says California Water Tunnel Will Cost $20 Billion. Officials and Experts Say It's Worth ItDavid DePape Sentenced to 30 Years in Federal Prison for Attack on Nancy Pelosi's HusbandFederal Judge Orders New Sentencing Hearing for David DePape in Trial Over Pelosi AttackProsecutors to Push for Terrorism Enhancement in Sentencing of David DePape, Who Bludgeoned Paul Pelosi in 2022UC Santa Cruz Academic Workers to Strike Over University's Treatment of Pro-Palestinian ProtestersSonoma State University's Deal With Student Protesters in Limbo After President's RemovalDutch Research Team Recounts the Long-Term Effects of StarvationSome Bay Area Universities Reach Deal to End Encampments, but Students Say Their Fight ContinuesEighth-Grader's Call to 911 About Teacher's Outburst Causes StirHighway 1 to Big Sur Has Reopened — What to Know About Visiting from the Bay Area