Tax Day Reveals Many Californians Are in Financial Straits

Save ArticleSave Article

Failed to save article

Please try again

A sticky note that says "Tax Day" is posted on a W-9 form.
 (Getty Images)

Today, as millions of Californians rush to file their tax returns and apply for tax credits, state lawmakers are returning to Sacramento from an 11-day spring recess — and preparing to resume negotiations over the best way to put money back in residents’ pockets.

The two events are interrelated: The amount of tax revenue collected by the state will help determine the size, form and scope of the financial relief on which Gov. Gavin Newsom and legislators finally settle.

But Tax Day also is a reminder of the staggering divide between California’s haves and have-nots, which the state’s progressive tax structure brings out in stark relief: In 2019, the fewer than 100,000 Californians who earned at least $1 million paid about 40% of the state’s personal income taxes, according to data obtained by The Los Angeles Times.

By contrast, 77% of Californians who filed income tax returns that year reported an income of less than $100,000 — and 50% reported earnings below $50,000.

The financial precariousness many Californians experience was highlighted in a new poll from UC Berkeley’s Institute of Governmental Studies, and The Los Angeles Times:

  • Sixty-four percent of California voters said they pay too much in state and federal income taxes, up 10 percentage points from six years ago.
  • Forty-two percent of voters said they’re financially worse off than they were a year ago, double the 21% who said they were better off — the opposite of 2016, when about 48% of voters said they were financially better off than they were the prior year, nearly double the 25% who reported they were doing worse.

And even as California’s tight labor market helps some workers score higher wages — unions representing 47,000 grocery workers ratified a new contract Thursday that includes their biggest pay raises in decades — a whopping 8.5% year-over-year rise in the cost of goods is eating into those gains.


Unions representing workers ranging from classified employees in San Ysidro School District to California State University faculty say their wage increases don’t cover the cost of inflation.

Meanwhile, more than 8,000 Sutter Health employees are set to strike at more than a dozen Northern California facilities today to call for better health and safety standards.

Soaring inflation rates will make it harder for California to keep up the job gains it saw in March, said Michael Bernick, former director of the state Employment Development Department and an attorney at Duane Morris.

The state’s jobless rate fell to 4.9% in March — down from a revised rate of 5.3% in February — as the state added 60,200 non-farm payroll jobs, EDD announced Friday.

  • Gov. Gavin Newsom: EDD’s report “is more good news for California’s continued economic recovery, representing thousands of new opportunities for workers throughout the state.”
  • Michael Bernick: “We’re likely to see a far greater slowdown in job growth throughout 2022 as the impacts of inflationary government spending begin to be felt.”