A Theater Critic and a Hotel Maid Are on the Case in Two Captivating Mystery Novels

How could I resist a suspense novel in which a critic becomes an amateur detective in order to avoid becoming a murder suspect or even a victim? I inhaled Alexis Soloski’s debut thriller, Here in the Dark; but, even readers who don’t feel a professional kinship with Soloski’s main character should be drawn to this moody and erudite mystery. Soloski, who herself is a theater critic for The New York Times, nods to other stories like the classic noir, Laura, and even the screwball comedy, The Man Who Came to Dinner, where a critic takes center stage.

Our troubled 30-something year old heroine, Vivian Parry, has been the junior theater critic at a New York magazine for years. After a serious breakdown in college, Vivian feels OK about the “small life” she created for herself consisting of a walk-up apartment in the East Village; and lots of casual sex, drinking and theater.

Here’s how Vivian explains herself:

Warmth is not my forte. As far as the rich palette of human experience goes, I live on a gray scale. Aristotle said that drama was an imitation of an action. I am, of necessity, an imitation of myself — a sharp smile, an acid joke, an abyss where a woman should be. …

Except when I’m seeing theater, good theater. When I’m in the dark, at that safe remove from daily life, I feel it all — rage, joy, surprise. Until the houselights come on and break it all apart again, I am alive.

Vivian’s notorious prickliness, however, may be her undoing. The position of chief critic at the magazine has become vacant and Vivian is competing for it against a likeable colleague whom she describes as having “a retina-scarring smile, and the aesthetic discernment of a wedge salad.”

When a graduate student requests an interview with Vivian and her participation on a panel on criticism, Vivian thinks this outside validation may just tip the odds for promotion in her favor. Instead, she becomes a person of interest to the police after that grad student vanishes and she discovers the corpse of a stranger in a nearby park.

Is this just a series of unfortunate events or is something more sinister going on? Vivian starts investigating on her own, which puts her in the sights of Russian mobsters and a sexually vicious police detective who could have been cast in Marat/Sade. Maybe Vivian should have played it safe and contented herself with writing snarky reviews of Rockettes holiday shows.

Soloski, too, might have played it safe, but, fortunately for us readers she didn’t. Instead of writing a coy send-up of a theatrical thriller, she’s written a genuinely disturbing suspense tale that explores the theater of cruelty life can sometimes be.

Critics should be aware of their biases. For instance I know that given a choice, I’ll pass up a cozy mystery and reach for the hard stuff. That’s why I missed Nita Prose’s mega bestselling cozy debut, The Maid, when it came out nearly two years ago. A mystery featuring a hotel maid named Molly seemed to promise a lot of heartwarming fluff.

Heartwarming, yes; but the only fluff in The Maid — and in its new sequel, The Mystery Guest — is the kind stuffed into the pillows of the Regency Grand Hotel.

At the center of both novels is our narrator, Molly Gray, a sensitive young woman who processes the world differently. She’s hyper-attentive to details: a tiny smudge on a TV remote, say, but not so sharp when it comes to reading people. That’s why the meaner employees at the Regency Grand mockingly call her names like “Roomba the Robot.”

In The Mystery Guest, Molly, who’s now “head maid,” has to clean up a real mess: A famous mystery writer who’s signing books at the Regency keels over dead, the victim of foul play.

It turns out Molly knew this writer because her beloved late grandmother was his maid. Of course, he failed to recognize Molly because he’s one of those people who just looks through the help and their kin.

The Mystery Guest takes readers into Molly’s childhood and fills in the backstory — some of it painful — of her grandmother’s life. Like Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple, who’s rendered invisible because she’s an old woman, Molly and her grandmother are not seen because of the kind of work they do. In this affecting and socially-pointed mystery series, however, invisibility becomes the superpower of the pink-collar proletariat.

Copyright 2023 Fresh Air. To see more, visit Fresh Air.