Thao Corruption Trial: FBI Tape Shows Defendant Lying, Prosecution Says

On one of the final days of testimony in Sheng Thao’s Oakland corruption trial, prosecutors played new audio recordings that they say show one of the defendants lying.
The interview, between Oakland businessman Andy Duong and FBI Special Agent Tyler Nave, took place on June 20, 2024, just hours after the FBI raided his home, along with the home Thao shared with her longtime partner, Andre Jones, and the home of Andy Duong’s father, David Duong, whose family owns California Waste Solutions, the city’s recycling contractor. The company’s headquarters was also raided. The four were indicted months later on charges of bribery, conspiracy and fraud. They’ve pleaded not guilty.
In the audio clips from the interview, Andy Duong denies that the housing start-up he cofounded, Evolutionary Homes, ever paid Jones or employed him as a contractor.
In the recording, Nave asks Andy Duong: “Was Jones ever paid by you guys?” referring to Evolutionary Homes.
“No, he’s not our consultant,” Andy Duong can be heard responding.

Prosecutors allege the Duongs bribed Thao by offering to pay Jones through a no-show job at Evolutionary Homes in exchange for Thao’s help securing a contract with the company, among other favors. Earlier in the trial, U.S. attorneys presented two checks from April and November 2023 detailing some of those payments, along with a written agreement investigators obtained stating Jones would work as a contractor for the company.
But under cross-examination, Andy Duong’s counsel implied that Nave’s questioning in the 2024 interview was too vague.
“You used the phrase ‘you guys,’” attorney Christine Bonomo said. “You did not say the words ‘Evolutionary Homes’ in that question, [did you]?”
“I did not,” Nave replied.
In his interview with the FBI, Andy Duong denied having any knowledge of the checks investigators presented or of the written agreement.

When pressed, he doubled down, telling investigators: “I don’t know where that come from.”
“I’m not the superior, I don’t authorize … even if this was present[ed] to me,” Andy Duong told Nave.
Jones’ defense attorneys have argued Jones had a legitimate job as a consultant with Evolutionary Homes in 2023, citing his name on multiple company presentations, an independent contractor agreement and a request that he receive Evolutionary Homes business cards.
But Andy Duong told investigators in the June 2024 interview he “never talked to Jones anything about Evolutionary Homes.”
“I never even talk to Andre Jones about anything at all, pretty much at all,” he can be heard saying on the recording. “I don’t even in contact with that guy.”
Andy Duong also appeared to downplay his relationship with Thao, saying he knew her as a staffer in City Hall back in 2014, when California Waste Solutions was pursuing a city contract. The two were friends when she was a city staffer for Councilmember Rebecca Kaplan, he said, but their relationship changed after Thao was elected to the city council in 2018.
“Ever since she got elected in terms of council, she’s gotten kind of arrogant and kind of distant [from] us,” he can be heard telling the agents.
Thao stared with pursed lips at a transcript of the conversation playing on screens throughout the courtroom. Across the defendants’ table, Andy Duong watched another screen, facing away from Thao.
He told investigators that during her mayoral campaign, her consultant asked him and his family to introduce her to business leaders and voters, but that he never donated to her campaign.
“Just because they here in Oakland doesn’t mean I would support whatever, whoever,” he said.
Later in the interview, Andy Duong made a joke to the investigators, saying: “Now you the mayor, you don’t even want to give me a high five?”
Andy Duong’s responses to the investigators seemed to contradict several recorded phone calls between Andy Duong and Thao, including one from April 2019, when Thao can be heard relaying details of a conversation council members had during a closed-session meeting about a lawsuit between the city and California Waste Solutions. She appears to be advising Andy Duong on how to prepare for a meeting with city officials the following day.


Throughout the trial, prosecutors have displayed photographs of Thao and Andy Duong together at campaign events and a dinner. She also attended a trade delegation to Vietnam with both Andy and David Duong in the summer of 2023.
The recordings of the FBI interview capped off more than a month of sometimes heated testimony, during which momentum has swung back and forth between the prosecutors and defense attorneys.
U.S. attorneys have called to the witness stand former city staffers, federal investigators and two people who have pleaded guilty to engaging in illicit business deals with the Duongs to corroborate their tale of the pay-to-play scheme.
The government’s star witness and alleged co-conspirator in the scheme, Mario Juarez, outlined in painstaking detail over eight days of testimony how he and the Duongs struck the alleged agreement with Thao, giving context to cryptic text messages and boardroom exchanges. And earlier this week, Brian Azevedo, a former San Leandro council member, testified that he’d accepted a bribe from the Duongs to help sell housing units from Evolutionary Homes to his city through an arrangement similar to the one prosecutors say Thao agreed to.
But defense attorneys have also attempted to cast doubt on whether many of those key witnesses and the troves of texts, emails and recordings truly prove the government’s case. They’ve focused on discrediting testimony from Juarez, painting him as a slighted business partner who’s spun a vengeful story to frame their clients and cut a deal that gets him out of serious trouble.
Next week, the parties could make their final pitches about the true relationships between the parties. Then, the case will be the jury’s to decide.
