Proposed Tobacco Ban Sparks Fiery Debate in Beverly Hills

A fiery debate is breaking out across Beverly Hills as people at tony hair salons, gas stations and stores weigh in on whether the city of the rich and famous should become the first in the U.S. to outlaw the sale of tobacco products everywhere except for a few cigar lounges.

The City Council decided Tuesday night to make some changes to the proposal, such as allowing guests in the city’s luxury hotels to acquire cigarettes through their concierge or room service. Members indicated they plan to pass the amended measure May 21.

Abstainers have said yes to the idea, and the sooner the better, while smokers protested, no way.

“It’s a ridiculous idea,” hair stylist Giuseppe Franco shouted soon after lighting up a Marlboro Light on a breezeway just outside the upscale hair salon that bears his name.

“First off, let’s be honest. Smoking is bad. I don’t let my daughter smoke,” he said during a sometimes profane tirade delivered between puffs. “But it’s going to hurt my friends,” he said, pointing out that a 24-hour Rite Aid pharmacy down the street does big business in cigarettes that go for about $8 a pack.

So does the Union 76 gas station a couple blocks away, where the cashier says they sell about 50 packs a day at $12 apiece.

California is among at least 25 states that outlaw smoking in workplaces, restaurants and bars. It also has one of the highest cigarette taxes in the country at nearly $3 a pack.

Beverly Hills already restricts the sale of menthol cigarettes and other flavored tobacco products.

But the proposed ordinance would go much further, banning all tobacco products from grocery stores, pharmacies, hotels and gas stations in the city of 34,000 people between West Hollywood and Los Angeles.

“My celebrity clients smoke,” Franco fumed.

Like most Beverly Hills business people, Franco won’t name them, but he did pull out a copy of the hotel magazine Concierge featuring a photo of him with his buddy Arnold Schwarzenegger, a cigar aficionado.

Cigar smokers most likely won’t have to sacrifice if the ordinance is adopted. A city staff report recommends exempting three tony cigar lounges in Beverly Hills.

Still, the folks at one of them, Nazareth’s Fine Cigars, weren’t happy.

“They’re going to chase the tourists out of here,” said retired businessman John Davis as he relaxed in a lounge chair, cigar in hand.

The decision came after the five-member council heard two hours of sometimes emotional but always polite testimony from scores of people on both sides of the issue.

Owners of gas stations and other small businesses said the ban could force them to lay-off people. Health advocates said while they regretted that possibility, people’s health was more important.

Scott McGuff, a regional manager for Rite Aide, said the Beverly Hills pharmacy draws many customers from nearby luxury hotels who pick up both cigarettes and other items and it will lose them with the ban.

“It’s going to affect layoffs, that’s how big of a deal it is for me,” he said.

While council members sympathized, they said the public’s health was too important for Beverly Hills not to take action.

“We are charged with providing for the public health and that’s really what this conversation is about, said Councilman Julian Gold.

These days, many people visit Beverly Hills from Asia and Europe, where smoking is commonplace, Davis said earlier from the cigar lounge. They’ll have to head to West Hollywood to buy their smokes because cigarette sales would be banned in famous places like the Beverly Wilshire, the hotel where Julia Roberts’ character stayed in “Pretty Woman.”

Not everyone in Beverly Hills is a wealthy celebrity, of course. While the median price of a home is more than $2 million and the median annual income is more than $103,000, about 9% of the population falls below the poverty line, according to the U.S. Census.

The gas stations, pharmacies and other places offering modest jobs and cigarettes are tucked into corners just off Rodeo Drive and other fashionable streets. Only 28 sell tobacco products, according to the city staff report.

The city report cites the hazards of smoking and the desire of Beverly Hills to be a healthy city as reasons for the ban on tobacco sales.

For non-smokers Oscar Melendez and Cezar Diaz, that’s reason enough to support it.

“I can pick up cigarette smoke from 30 feet away,” Melendez said.

At the fashionable Sarah Pacini clothing store, it gets so bad that Diaz, the manager, said he sometimes has to close the door and ask smokers not to stand on the sidewalk out front.

Most, he said, respond politely.