Decoding School Board Races on Your Ballot

Airdate: Tuesday, October 27, 2026 at 9 am
Voters across the Bay Area will weigh in on more than 100 school board races in next Tuesday’s election. As many school districts face declining enrollment, tight budgets and difficult decisions about the role of technology in classrooms, the make-up of school boards is critical. But voters often have very little information about the candidates, what they stand for or who supports them. This year, to address that void, KQED sent questionnaires to close to 400 school board candidates to better understand their positions. We’ll talk about the issues facing school boards, how to make an informed vote and the key races in San Francisco, Oakland and beyond.
Guest:
- Jill Tucker, K-12 Education Reporter, San Francisco Chronicle
- Molly Gibbs, education reporter, The Mercury News and East Bay Times
- Katie DeBenedetti, reporter, KQED
- Ashley McBride, education equity reporter, The Oaklandside
Episode Transcript
This is a computer-generated transcript. While our team has reviewed it, there may be errors.
Scott Shafer: Welcome to Forum. I’m Scott Shafer in today for Alexis Madrigal. Well, as next week’s election approaches, voters are being inundated with ads online, on television and radio and in the mail with slate card endorsements for propositions, congressional races and statewide offices. But below those top of the ballot contests are more than a hundred school board seats up for grabs throughout the Bay Area. Public school board members vote on district budgets. They decide on classroom policies in curriculum. All at a time of shrinking student populations and often less funding. This hour, we’re gonna look at the importance of school board elections and what’s at stake. Joining me for this first segment are Jill Tucker. She covers education, K through 12 education for the San Francisco Chronicle. Jill, good to see you.
Jill Tucker: Good to see you too, Scott.
Scott Shafer: And also with me here in the studio, KQED’s Katie DiBenedetti. Hey, Katie. Hi, Scott. Let me start with you, Katie, you have been covering this issue for our Voter Guide and elsewhere. You wrote a story for KQED called Don’t Skip the School Board Races on Your Ballot, because they are less and there’s less information. Talk a little bit about how you approached this for the voter guide.
Katie DiBenedetti: Yeah, so this was kind of something that KQED wanted to do is just give more information to voters about school board races. These are often what is called low information, which basically means that voters know very little about who the candidates are or where they stand on key issues. And so we noticed that a lot of the issues that school districts are facing are pretty similar. And so we sent out a questionnaire to. About 400 candidates across the Bay Area asking them how they feel about a number of key issues. So cell phone policies, if they support law enforcement agents on campus and other questions related to budgets and these really key issues that are affecting school districts.
Scott Shafer: So I think we said there are over nearly 400 candidates running for all of these Bay Area seats. So I’m just curious, like ballpark percentage of people who actually responded to the survey.
Katie DiBenedetti: Yeah, I think we got over, I don’t know the final count, but I think around 200 maybe candidates responded, which is pretty impressive. I think that, you know, some of the seats also are running uncontested. Some candidates haven’t really mounted like a very robust campaign, but a lot of people to get back to us.
Scott Shafer: Was there consensus, would you say, among the candidates that responded in terms of these things like cell phones in classrooms? And I mean, it’s hard to answer a question about a school budget, I guess, just because it’s so abstract.
Katie DiBenedetti: Totally, some issues more than others. I think a lot of people in, you know, San Francisco were a lot more of the urban districts. Across the board were pretty unsupportive of like say law enforcement officers on campus. And also had a lot of consensus on no cell phones in schools. But some of the other issues, especially in suburban districts were much more varied.
Scott Shafer: Yeah, like, give me an example, like what’s an issue that’s affecting, I don’t know, some place in Mill Valley that isn’t affecting Oakland.
Katie DiBenedetti: Well, I think a lot of the issues are similar, but like, for example, law enforcement officers out in the suburbs, out in Mill Valley, people are just less, you know, opposed. I think that voters in San Francisco and Oakland look at that and think, no, we, we don’t want any candidate who supports, you know, having law enforcement on campus versus in some of those other areas. That’s not really an issue that they work.
Scott Shafer: And Jill Tucker, you’ve been covering these school board elections and also just school board meetings for a long time. How would you characterize, you know, the role that these schoolboard members play in the running of a school district?
Jill Tucker: Yeah, the school board, as you said, they set the policy, they make these decisions, and sometimes it seems just very abstract. But the reality is those decisions trickle down into the classrooms. And they can be huge decisions, I mean, which is why you’re seeing at a national level the Trump administration investigating districts like San Francisco and other districts over, you know, these culture war issues. And so what school districts and school boards are doing in terms of transgender rights, transgender policies, math, literacy, all of those things are decided at the top. And so who sits on that school board? I mean, those eight to 10 hour meetings can seem incredibly boring, unending, but what happens in them and what they decide is critical.
Scott Shafer: So what would you say to a voter who wonders like, what should I be looking for? You know, there’s like all these candidates running. I don’t know a lot about them. You know maybe you don’t have kids in the school district where you’re voting. You know what are some of the things that are kind of indications about somebody’s qualifications or who’s supporting them and so on.
Jill Tucker: Yeah, I mean, I think a lot of people look to endorsements. So in cities like San Francisco and Oakland, they’re going to look at who the parent’s organization is endorsing or who the teacher’s union is endorsing or who they mayor and other politicians are endorsing. So they sort of start linking the school board candidates with who is aligned with them. And I think that that gives people a little bit of understanding of where they are in the political spectrum or what their general priorities or beliefs are.
Scott Shafer: And that could push a voter either way, depending on how they feel about that politician or that group. Yeah, exactly. And Katie, like, do you have a sense of, you know, are unions involved in the election? Obviously unions have a lot at stake in who gets elected to the school board. What are you hearing on that front?
Katie DiBenedetti: Yeah, definitely. I mean, teachers unions often or always, you know, have a slate of candidates that they support and often they do a very good job at getting their candidates elected. I think we’re really seeing that in Oakland, where the board majority is backed by the union and it’s really impacted the way that, you know, the board operates. They are very aligned with the superintendent, with the union and in kind of getting policies passed that the teachers there want. So I think It really you know, they have a lot of power.
Scott Shafer: Is there a divergence between what the teachers want, or what the unions want, and what’s best for the kids?
Katie DiBenedetti: I mean it depends if you ask anything
Scott Shafer: I’m asking you.
Katie DiBenedetti: I think sometimes, yeah, and I think that that’s, you know, fair, I mean, what the teachers are advocating for is what’s best for them, not necessarily that’s their job. So I think there can be a difference and there’s definitely, at least in San Francisco, a difference between who the teachers’ union is endorsing and who the parent groups are endorsing.
Scott Shafer: Joe, what’s your sense of that divergence between what the union might want, what the parents might want?
Jill Tucker: Yeah, I mean, sometimes they do align and certainly like parents support teachers, you know, like in the strike and things like that. But I will say the union exists to protect teachers and their working conditions and their compensation. That is their role. And so when you’re looking at what is best for the schools, people are looking at it through very different lenses. And, but, you know, as Katie said, the The teachers’ unions are very powerful, and they have a lot of money. And the state union will, you know, put money into local elections where they feel that it is incredibly critical. And in Oakland, for example, the division between the sides that are pro-teachers’ union and pro-candidates that are not endorsed by the teachers’ union is a very big divide and very critical in the upcoming election.
Scott Shafer: What’s an example of like an issue or two where they’re on opposite sides?
Jill Tucker: Yeah, I mean, I would say in Oakland, specifically, closing schools is a huge issue. The teachers union and their candidates are vehemently against closing any schools at all, whereas those that are more looking at the overall health of the district, looking at what needs to happen given declining enrollment, I mean, there are schools with, you know, a hundred students in them. And so you have the parents and former, even former school board members that have and actively campaigning. For candidates that are going to be more open-minded about all of these issues than the teachers here.
Scott Shafer: And Katie, just from watching the news, listening to the news. It does seem that some of the most emotional school board meetings are when there are school closures. And merging of schools is on the agenda. And that’s very much, maybe totally tied to the declining enrollment, right?
Katie DiBenedetti: Yeah, I mean, that’s definitely the biggest reason that districts are looking at closing schools is declining enrollment. There are schools with so few students in them, but it is really emotional. And I think that, you know, it’s been interesting to watch over the last couple of years because two years ago when San Francisco tried to close schools a few years before that, when Oakland tried to close schools, you kind of see that even some of the board members have moved positions like Mike Hutchinson in Oakland was on the forefront of reversing school closures When he this was like 2023, now he’s like, we need to possibly close school. So it’s really shifted. And even though it’s very unpopular with families and teachers and everyone, because it’s hard to close a school, I think that people are starting to kind of understand, maybe we, we do need to.
Scott Shafer: I don’t know if you can answer this, but a lot of times when there’s a big change of any kind, I’m thinking of same-sex marriage, the sky’s gonna fall, it’s gonna ruin everything. When you look back at some of these school closures, parents who were very unhappy didn’t want the schools to close, I mean, has it generally worked out okay?
Katie DiBenedetti: I mean, the last couple of years, we haven’t seen many of them go through. A lot of them have have been stopped. Um, I know that down in San Jose, there were some school closures. And I think that, you know, it’s a little too, too soon to tell there. I think parents are still pretty upset about the way that’s working out. But, but in general, I think this guy usually doesn’t fall.
Scott Shafer: What about you, Jill, would you add anything to that? So is it the public testimony that basically stops these mergers and closures from going ahead?
Jill Tucker: I mean, it’s political pressure, right? These are elected officials that are making the decision. And so when you have that much pushback from not only the public, but also other politicians, I think that the fear of losing their position or their power is very scary. But I will say when they have done that in places like Vallejo and even Oakland, what people see is that. The school isn’t emotional, they’re emotionally attached. But in general, a mom that I talked to that was one of those that took over a school in Oakland that was slated for closure.
Scott Shafer: What do you mean took over?
Jill Tucker: They they camped out inside and said, you know over the summer and said reverse it and we’re not leaving And they there was hunger strikes as well. There’s been a lot in Oakland But once that mom her kids moved to a different school I wrote a story about her where she was like I get it now My kids have after-school programs. They have dance They have you know all of these things because you they couldn’t have that in a school with 115. Yeah
Scott Shafer: Yeah. You can’t have it in two places with a small population. And, you know, Katie, the role of superintendents, I mean, it seems like they get buffeted by all these things, right? I mean just thinking back to COVID and how that affected education and enrollment and so on. You know, talk about the relationship between superintendants and school boards.
Katie DiBenedetti: Yeah. So I mean, the school board elects the super or, you know, chooses a superintendent. They have the ability to hire and fire them. And then the superintendent does a lot of the day-to-day governance, making a lot, a lot decisions, but you know their relationship with the board can be difficult. It can be contested, but also, you know, when they’re aligned, it makes it all work out.
Scott Shafer: That is Katie DiBenedetti from KQED, covering school boards for us. Katie, thanks so much for being here. We’re gonna continue this conversation, broaden it out to other school districts in the Bay Area. We’d love to hear from you. If you’re a parent, a student, a teacher, maybe a superintendent, 866-733-6786 is the number to call. Or you’ll find us on social media, Blue Sky Instagram. We’re at KQE forum. Or join our Discord community. And welcome back to Forum. I’m Scott Schafer here today for Alexis Madrigal. We’re talking about school board races throughout the Bay Area, how to figure out who to vote for. Talking with Jill Tucker, she covers K through 12 education for the San Francisco Chronicle. And joining us now, Molly Gibbs. She covers education for the Mercury News and East Bay Times. Molly, welcome.
Molly Gibbs: Hi, thank you.
Scott Shafer: And also joining us, Ashley McBride. She covers education equity for the Oakland side. Ashley, welcome to you as well.
Ashley McBride: Morning, Scott.
Scott Shafer: And once again, we’d love to hear from you. What are your thoughts about what’s happening in your school districts? Are you trying to decide who to vote for? What are you looking for in the candidates? Give us a call at 866-733-6786, 866 733-6 786. You can also email your comments and questions to forum at kqed.org. And you’ll find us on social media as well. Blue Sky Instagram, we’re at kquedforum. And you can also join our Discord community. I want to Molly, you cover the East Bay and the South Bay. We’ve been talking a lot about San Francisco and Oakland. What are you hearing and seeing and reporting on, you know, in Silicon Valley or some of these other parts of the Bay Area?
Molly Gibbs: Yeah, we’re seeing a couple of different trends kind of play out in some of these local elections. You know, you just talked a little bit about some school closures in San Jose Unified. They decided to close five elementary school campuses earlier this year. And in that race, we are really seeing what happens after you make that decision. How does that, you know, kind of, play out? And exactly what Jill said a little ago, which is that, those trustees are trying to regain some of the community’s trust. And so. You know, we’re really seeing the community demand transparency. That’s like, I would say the biggest trend that we’re seeing in that race.
Scott Shafer: Like around what kind of issue?
Molly Gibbs: Around how you make decisions around, you know, when do you close schools? What schools do you decide to close? How, you, know, program cuts, budget cuts, layoffs, all of that. So we’re really seeing that play out in that race. And a lot of, you now, local parents or people that were impacted directly by those closures have decided to run to kind of, promise to repair the community trust. I would say that’s the biggest thing that we’re seeing in San Jose Unified.
Scott Shafer: Yeah. Jill, you’re nodding. Have you also seen parents who were, you know, taking over schools or doing whatever, you know, involved at school board meetings deciding, you know what, I’m going to, I am going to run.
Jill Tucker: Yeah, every now and then, definitely they get angry enough, frustrated enough, and they’re attending the school board meetings anyway. They might as well be sitting where they can actually vote. So you definitely see parents, you know, whether they’re interested in one particular issue or many, jumping into the races. And that’s happening in San Francisco, and that’s happened in Oakland.
Scott Shafer: Ashley, what about in Oakland? Jill talked a little bit earlier about just budget cuts and some of the difficulties around closing or merging schools. What are you hearing, and how is it affecting students?
Ashley McBride: Yeah, I would say some of the issues that you all raise are what I’m seeing, the budget policy, cell phone policy has been a big topic of discussion this year, especially for students. Oakland Unified introduced a cell phone ban where students are not allowed to have their phones at all on them during the school day. We’ve seen the All-City Council Student Union do surveys and try to make some changes to that policy because they feel like they weren’t adequately consulted when the board introduced that. There’s also an interim superintendent in place right now in Oakland, and so the next school board that gets elected will have the responsibility of choosing the new permanent superintendent.
Scott Shafer: Well, and I think the district just came out of more than two decades of state oversight. So as they begin the process, or maybe they’re in the middle of it, of selecting a new superintendent, how does coming out of that oversight and having more independence, how does that affect the way things run there?
Ashley McBride: It definitely has a big impact. So this year is the first time in more than two decades that the OUSD school board has been in complete control of their own finances. They exited receivership in 2025. So this election is in part a referendum on how the school board leadership has handled that responsibility. There are some people who feel that the district is being taken down the wrong path and back up in receivership if the budget’s not reined in. As the incumbents, especially in districts two and four, who are backed by the teachers union, feel that their leaderships should have some more time to prove that the strategies and the budget cuts that they’re making are sustainable.
Scott Shafer: All right, I want to bring our listeners into the conversation. And again, the number to call 866-733-6786. You can also email your comments and questions to forum at KQED.org. And we’re going to start in Oakland and Addie, your first welcome.
Caller: Hi, yeah, so I live in Oakland. I’m concerned about racial equity and what it means for the candidates who are talking about school closures to also be backed by some serious moneyed interests. Like I know that the majority of schools closed in Oakland in like the 2000s before the current board majority came in and actually reversed them. Those closures were in majority black schools and there was actually a civil rights investigation where it found that the rights of black and disabled and low income students would be disproportionately hurt by these closures. Also the candidates who are putting these closures on the table, I’m hearing a lot about how they are funded by groups like Empower Oakland that are basically like packs funded by millionaires and billionaires and these AI and crypto executives. And so I just got asked like, why do they care so much about our school board race? What are the interests at play here? Is this a land grab? Is this the power grab? That really concerns me.
Scott Shafer: Eddie, what are you hearing from, if you’ve talked to some of these groups that are putting big money that’s happening in San Francisco as well, you know, what is their agenda? What are they, why are they so concerned about who wins these elections?
Ashley McBride: Do you mean Ashley? Ashley, I’m sorry.
Scott Shafer: Actually, I’m sorry. I’m so sorry. Eddie’s the caller. Sorry.
Ashley McBride: That’s okay. Um, yes, I actually will have a story out later today about the campaign finance in the OUSD board races And I think the pattern that I see is um, as you all talked about a little bit earlier the teacher’s union Um often has a lot of money that they put into the school board races And in the last few elections that i’ve observed there’s usually another group sometimes it’s aligned with like charter schools or other interests that um kind of oppose the Teachers Union’s slate of candidates. And so that’s what we’re seeing this year. OEA has its slate of candidate, the Oakland Education Association, Teachers Union, and then Empower Oakland has endorsed another slate of Candidates. There’s another new group this year called Oakland Parents for Quality Education that actually has gotten a lot of its funding also from Empower, Oakland, that is also endorsing the same slate of candidates as Empower. So there is a pretty big divide there. All right. This year. Yeah.
Scott Shafer: Eddie, thanks so much for the call. And I think we’re going to go now down to Gilroy. And Dan, you’re next. Welcome.
Caller: Yeah. Hi. Good morning. This is Dan. I’m calling from Dora and I’m currently a candidate for the school board. One of the reasons why I decided to run was, um, many of our school board trustees have been on the board for 12 plus years and often in fact, until recently, up until this race, they’ve run unopposed. So, you know, the parents don’t really have a choice when they’re voting because, uh, incumbents always get. Their seat back, which causes, you know, some, some policy issues as far as I’m concerned and present certain challenges with getting messages out to the students or, you know, revising policies.
Scott Shafer: Let me just put that to Molly. Gilroy, kind of in your territory there down, is that in Santa Clara County? I just drove through Gilroy coming back from Paso Robles. I wasn’t sure which county. It’s Southern, Southern Santa Clara. So is that, I mean, that’s got to be an issue in a lot of school districts.
Molly Gibbs: Yeah, we are, we’re seeing that in a lot of school districts. Um, you know, I would say it’s, it’s interesting, um, you know, not to bring it back to San Jose unified again, but I would say typically you would see maybe those same incumbents run unopposed. And in the case now we have two open seats and five candidates that are running. One of the trustees is not running for reelection. And so I do think it’s interesting to kind of see what happens when a community gets really upset and outraged and decides to kind of take matters into their own hands. And, you know, that often means more candidates than the typical incumbent.
Scott Shafer: Dan, are you running with a, like a platform that’s, uh, or priorities that are like vastly different from some of these incumbents that, uh you’re talking about?
Caller: I am. In fact, uh, you know, the main thing that I’m running for is our teachers and Gilroy are paid amongst the lowest in Santa Clara County. So this is causing massive turnover in our school district. And these, um, these teachers who are really good educators are going further south to school districts like Campbell and, um Stoneyville and Mountain View for 10 to $1,000 more. And this, this creates a constant burning churn, but what makes it versus… The same thing is happening with our para-educators who are, you know, they’re, they’re I don’t want to say abused, but they go through a great amount of physical and emotional anguish trying to teach kids, um, especially when, you know we don’t have enough, our educators, one of our existing school board trustee members who is the past president, uh, for 20 years in your life school district. Stated in in one of the meetings that people should suck it up and the top ronan wall being in there their stripes and back just matches for you know that was the point of which i decided to run
Scott Shafer: Well, thanks for calling in, Dan. Really appreciate that. It’s great to hear the perspective of a candidate who is running. Jill, you know, Molly was talking a moment ago about when parents really get upset. I mean, in San Francisco, during COVID, there was a recall of three school board members over various issues, renaming of schools, changing admission standards at Lowell and other things. Is that unusual? Uh, for, for people to get so upset that they actually try to recall school remembers that I seem to remember that something similar happening around some of these social issues like down in maybe Temecula, Chino Hills, something like that.
Jill Tucker: Yeah, definitely. I mean, the culture war issues bring out some of the biggest emotions. And so you’re going to see that happening, where there’ll be challengers that jump in that normally in the past, you might see somebody running unopposed or that type of thing. And so, yeah, I mean I think we’ve seen it in San Francisco with the recall. We’ve seen, we’re seeing it right now in Oakland, where, there’s sort of this grassroots effort that has been now sponsored with with funding but grassroots of parents and former school board members and things like that that have jumped in to campaign for other Candidates that wouldn’t necessarily get a leg up in running against a an incumbent
Scott Shafer: Yeah. Molly, the caller Dan, who’s running for the school board down there in Gilroy, talked about low teacher salaries and how you can jump to a neighboring school district and make more money. I mean, it’s. Just as someone who doesn’t observe this super closely, but it seems that oftentimes you get these pay races. There’s a strike or something, they increase salaries and then not long afterwards, there’s school closures. Because the money has to come from somewhere and you’ve got schools with declining enrollments, less funding from the state and that kind of thing. How do they balance that?
Molly Gibbs: It’s tough, it’s really tough. And I think, you know, post COVID, we’re really seeing a lot of these school districts have to come to a decision point, right? The one-time funding that they got from the state and federal government has officially dried up and they are having to really downsize and address for less students than they may have had years prior. And they have to decide, are we going to go the layoff route? That’s tough when you have a really vocal teachers union as we kind of touched on earlier. Or are you going to go program cuts, academic cuts, or in worst case scenarios, are you going to have to actually downsize and close schools? It’s a really hard conversation.
Scott Shafer: All right, let’s go back to the phones. And again, I’ll give out the number. It’s 866-733-6786, 866 733-6 786, or you can email us. It’s forum at kqed.org. Or if you prefer, you can send us a message on blue sky Instagram. We’re at KQED forum and let’s go to San Francisco. Now, Decker, you’re next.
Caller: Hello, I’ve heard a rumor that in 2028 SFUSD is looking to create more community schools Sorry, my voice is going out By eliminating some of the specialty programs like the Japanese bilingual bicultural program at Clarendon, Claire Lillian Falls, Korean West Portals Program and rooftops to create More Community School District. What does that mean?
Scott Shafer: Community school districts. What do you mean by community school district or community school?
Caller: The community schools are like neighborhood schools.
Scott Shafer: Oh, I see. As opposed to drawing people from all over the city. Jill, can you shed any light on that?
Jill Tucker: Yeah, the school board just voted to change the enrollment system, the student assignment system in San Francisco to one where students are automatically assigned to their neighborhood schools. But they will still, families will still have choice under this decision to also apply for district-wide programs. And that includes language programs, that includes special education programs and other types of things that they consider citywide magnet. Type programs. And so at this point, what programs there will be in schools, they’re looking to expand language immersion programs, and then look at what other additional programs they might want to add to give parents some choice in addition to their neighborhood school assignment.
Scott Shafer: Decker, thanks for the call. I’m wondering if this issue of trying to pick a school, trying to get into a school. The lottery has been so controversial in San Francisco. Ashley, to what extent are you hearing about that in the East Bay, in Oakland, and elsewhere?
Ashley McBride: Um, it’s not necessarily something I hear about frequently, but I mean, it does come up in the school closure conversation when boards are having to decide, you know, which schools do we close enrollment and like demand rates as far as how many families are wanting to go to that school is something that comes up and something that boards think should be considered. Um, another part of the school, closure conversation that I wanted to mention is Port- Board directors also have to grapple with, what do you do with the buildings? Oakland Unified has buildings that have been vacant for years and they have just become blighted lots. They’ve been targets for graffiti, they’ve had fires. And so neighbors in those communities are begging the district to do something and not just leave them to deteriorate. So another thing to keep in mind is, if you’re going to close a school, people want the district to have a real plan to do something with the building afterwards.
Scott Shafer: We’re talking about school board elections, lots of candidates running for about 109 school board slots in the Bay Area, and we’d love to hear from you. Give us a call, 866-733-6786. Let’s go now to Berkeley, and Megan, you’re next. Welcome.
Caller: Hello.
Scott Shafer: Hi, go right ahead.
Caller: Yes, hi, I’m calling from Berkeley and we have a race right now that has three uncontested BFT endorsed candidates that didn’t feel like they needed to let the voters know what they stand for. And it was uncontested race until last week when a parent and the co-founder of Berkeley unplugged, Rachie Lee threw her hat in as a registered write-in candidate. Basically the parent community feels like the board has effectively silence the community they’ve excluded the public in many ways from participating
Scott Shafer: That’s a, it’s tough to, tough to win as a write-in candidate, huh?
Caller: She also ran in 2022 and missed the seat by about a 1% vote. So she’s well known in the community. And we have been working hard through Berkeley Unplugged to get our board to look at the unrestricted technology use in our schools and looking for ways to let the board know about the numerous safety problems that our high school is having. So I think It is a tough race, but I think the parents want to be seen and heard at this moment and want our kids to have a seat on the board.
Scott Shafer: Thanks so much. Jill, are you aware of the writing candidate there in that Berkeley seat?
Jill Tucker: Yeah, that’s new news to me, and so I think that’s really interesting. It does exemplify some of the anger and frustration that we’re seeing in communities across the Bay Area with the school board. And I think a lot of times the school boards are kind of invisible to voters. They see it on their ballot, and they see incumbent, and their like, I’ll check that box. Uh… And so they don’t uh… That you know it’s really judges really i don’t know uh… End so uh… You know what we see is just sort of that that that uh… That that uh… Incumbents reelected and not a lot of interest really in in learning about uh… Who’s running
Scott Shafer: All right, Megan, thanks very much for that. A little bit of news over in Berkeley. We’re gonna continue our conversation about school board elections. Why they matter, what you might be looking for when you decide on the various candidates. Give us a call now at 866-733-6786. Again, 866 733 6786. You can also email your comments and questions to forum at kqed.org and you’ll find us on social media as well. We’re at KQED Forum. And welcome back to Forum. Scott Schaeffer here today for Alexis Madrigal. We’re talking about school board elections. There are a lot of them here in the Bay Area. Talking with Ashley McBride, she’s the education equity reporter for the Oakland side. Also Molly Gibbs, education reporter for The Mercury News and East Bay Times. And Jill Tucker, who’s been covering K-12 education for The Chronicle for many years. We’d love to hear from you. Give us a call at 666-733-6786. We’ve got some comments also. I’ll read one of them here from Jeff who writes on Discord, thanks to ChatGPT, this is the first school board election that I really felt like I understood all the candidates and the issues. Jill, you’re making a face. Uh, I mean, buyer beware, I guess, for one thing, but, uh, right. I mean. But there is a lot of information out there, but you gotta, they can’t assume it’s accurate.
Jill Tucker: No, right, exactly. I think you always have to check AI for the information, but I think it’s wonderful that, you know, people are able to sort of type in maybe what their interests are and be able to identify candidates that may align with that. I Think it’s great. The more information and the more people that are getting information or trying to get information about school board races is fantastic. So yay.
Scott Shafer: Yay, exactly. Wendy in San Francisco writes, I want to vote for people on the school board that will focus on school issues and not make proclamations regarding international issues that only divide people and that are performative. How do I find out which candidates in San Francisco focus only on school issue? Well, you can go to the KQED Voter Guide. Chronicle has its endorsements. I’m sure other publications do as well. Any advice For Wendy on that Molly
Molly Gibbs: Um, I would say I would look at endorsements of some candidates, of some, you know, some groups that you support, um, I’d look at their campaign websites and see, you know, what are some of their top issues. Normally, in that case, I say they would probably mention a similar, uh, desire. And yeah, I just, uh really try and read up on some of their, their priorities.
Scott Shafer: Does Ballotpedia include school board elections? Because they do. You’re nodding yes. So that can also be a good source. And yeah, go to the campaign websites. But kudos to everybody who’s trying to figure out who should they vote for. Because it’s not always obvious and not easy. During the break, Jill, we were talking about how some school districts have gone to dividing up the district, like some board of supervisors here in San Francisco, into districts. Talk about that why that has happened and what impact it has.
Jill Tucker: Yeah, so over the last handful of years, instead of having citywide elections for school board, meaning like in San Francisco, which has remained that, if there are three seats, the top three vote getters are on the school board. And so everybody runs for the school boards citywide. But in the past handful of year, there have been lawsuits against school districts to go to these district elections within a school district. So this video is carved up. And the school board members represent one district in the city, and the idea is to ensure that the schoolboard demographically represents the city and isn’t predominantly one race or another. And so that’s what these lawsuits have been about. But the implications of it are that you have even a city like Oakland, where they’re carving it up into seven regions for the election, you have maybe… An incumbent plus one, which is what we’re seeing, running for the school board. Because getting candidates to run for what is a very thankless, very low-paid, non-full-time job is very difficult. But you’re also seeing this in small districts, where they’re carving it up. And essentially, trying to get two people to run is almost impossible.
Scott Shafer: Yeah, and just to be clear, they don’t pay much. If anything, maybe a little per diem. Yeah, there’s a little stipend.
Jill Tucker: Yeah, there’s a little stipend. They get about five, in San Francisco, they get about $500 a month to be a school board member and some healthcare. But in general, it is definitely not a full-time job to support people other than in LA. But, you know, so what you see even in Oakland is that a schoolboard candidate will win the seat with about 6,000 votes. That means a lot of aren’t voting in that race at all, or… There’s two candidates, it splits, and so it’s a very small number of people that are electing these officials to the school board.
Scott Shafer: All right, let’s go back to the phones now and we’re going to go up to Sacramento and Michael, you’re next. Welcome.
Caller: Hi, good morning. Thanks for taking my call. I was a teacher for about eight to nine years before I finally left. And when I did leave the classroom, I learned that there were five different employees that were covering down for me, just to meet all the different expectations that I had to meet. And if you add up all their pay, I don’t think it would add up to what I was getting compensated. And I’m probably not the only one that decided, you know, hey this is not worth the stress and I’m leaving. So couple that with falling birth rates for you know my generation Millennials and you were not having children so they’re not going to be enrolling in schools. When I hear about these school closures, I guess my question is like, is this something more existential where public schools as we know it are just not going to return to what they were, and are just unsustainable, and do I even bother getting back into education or do I just up and leave into the private sector where maybe education is going?
Scott Shafer: Yeah, it’s really a profound question. Ashley McBride, any thoughts about that? I mean, it does get tough for the salary and everything that teachers have to deal with in the classroom. It’s so demanding and tough, and often they don’t get the respect they deserve and they have to put up with sometimes people in Washington, you know, making their lives even more difficult.
Ashley McBride: Yeah, it’s definitely a balancing act. I mean, Oakland Unified this year settled a contract with teachers offering them, I think, an 11% to 13% pay raise. And we’re able to narrowly avert a strike. It would have been the third open-ended strike by Oakland teachers since 2019. But the points that the caller raised are correct, like the demographic shifts that we’re seeing, as well as people just moving out of Oakland and moving out of California. Means that there’s not a lot of students to bring back into Oakland. I mean, 20 years ago, the district had like 50,000 students enrolled today. It’s about 33,000. And I don’t think there’s a world where a USD will reach 50,00 students again. So it is an existential question about how, what is the most efficient way to run schools and how do you also offer competitive salaries for teachers to be in those classrooms?
Scott Shafer: Michael, first of all, thank you for being a teacher. But when you think about leaving the profession, what do you think of what options you’re looking at?
Caller: Well, I had a son most recently, too, and I guess, you know, I go back and forth with it. I think, well, if I go into teaching, you know what, I’d go into the same school that my son is in, but I was getting so frustrated working there. I don’t know if I want my son to see me at work. Um, but, um, you know, I think at the end of the day, I think it does come down to like the labor market and saying, well, if I could, you know, make as much money somewhere else with less stress, I’ll take it. Um, cause I, I got to factor that in. We, we teachers, you know, we’re not getting into it for the money. We all hear that, but you know what the cost of right, you don’t like going up and then being able to afford a home one day, you know, might as well jump ship now or go down with it. I don’t know what to do.
Scott Shafer: Well, Michael, we certainly understand that dilemma and wish you the best. And again, thanks for being in the classroom. Thank you for taking my call. Yeah. You know, one of the things that school boards are sometimes used for, especially here in San Francisco, Jill, is a jumping off point for higher office. We have a lot of people, Matt Haney, who was on the school board, went to the Board of Supes, now he’s in the assembly. He might be running for the Senate. If Scott Wiener wins that congressional seat, Jane Kim, same thing. She’s now running for insurance commissioner. Um, what are your thoughts about that? I mean, is that a bad thing inherently or not?
Jill Tucker: I don’t know that it’s a bad thing inherently. I think if somebody is running for the school board solely to run for higher office, and they don’t really have a big interest in education, then that’s probably not going to serve the community well. That said, I think a lot of candidates that want to go into politics are interested in education as much as anybody who is not doesn’t. Doesn’t want to go on to higher office. So, you know, you can look at somebody like Matt Haney, who started on the school board very young, didn’t have kids, still doesn’t, but was passionate about education, still is as he’s moved through the legislature. You know, whether you support him or not, his interest in education was there. So it really is looking at these candidates and assessing exactly what they’re trying to do. School boards have always been a stepping zone. Uh… You know people are interested in politics or you know and they start there and they move up just like you know anybody running for city council then might move up to the state uh… But it really takes you know a savvy voter to look at what are the motivations of each person
Scott Shafer: Yeah. Do you think, Molly, that in some way having, quote-unquote, ambitious, and that don’t mean that in the pejorative way, but you know, people who are looking at the school board as maybe the first step, are they more likely to behave in a certain way and vote for things, you know? One way versus another because, let’s say, they want the union endorsement when they’re running for that higher office.
Molly Gibbs: I mean, I’ve talked to parents that certainly think that they do. I would say, yeah, I mean it depends on who you ask, but I know that in San Jose Unified there is a parent that is now running for the school board on, you know, her campaign promise is kind of like, I’m not a career politician. I am a local parent. I am directly in this community and I really care about what happens.
Scott Shafer: You know, I guess the flip side is then you have one of the earlier callers talking about incumbents who stick around forever. There are no term limits for school boards and not saying there should be, but let’s go down to Menlo Park now and Julia, welcome to Forum.
Caller: Hi thank you so much for having me in a big fan of the show grace um… I wanted to call in from the perspective of an educator and also a parent to uh… And the koi union high school district to experience date school closure and really speak to uh.. The profound change that that creates not only in the parent community but also for the students. And I think earlier on, a caller mentioned that marginalized populations are, you know, disproportionately affected by school closures. Historically, that is absolutely true. And I just want to kind of take a moment to hold that in the case of Tide Academy, that really served kids with disabilities extremely well. The closure of that school really shined a light on what folks think of as a very affluent district. Also making decisions that further marginalized kids who are already on the fringes. And the other thing I ask the panel is, Tide Academy was a very young school, and it was made possible by a $50 million bond measure. And I’m wondering, you know, what taxpayers pay for a school to be opened and that a structural deficit is named as the reason to close it. What happens to those taxpayer dollars, and why don’t taxpayers get more of a say?
Scott Shafer: That’s a really great question. Anybody, Molly, Jill?
Jill Tucker: Ashley? I would say, and I grew up in Sequoia Union, go to Sequoias High School in Redwood City, but I think in general, it’s difficult in those situations because people are voting for the bond, which is very separate than voting for school board races.
Scott Shafer: And that’s usually like infrastructure.
Jill Tucker: Yeah, it’s all facilities and large projects, typically. And so, ultimately, in a representative democracy, the voter has the ability to vote for the bond or not, and then hold the elected officials accountable by re-electing them or recalling them more or not. And so… But, you know, involvement in school districts, going to school board meetings, voting, paying attention to who is running so that. When those people are elected, people had a say in that. And I think that what happens is people are elected to school boards, and then after the fact, they’re sort of like, oh, I wish I would have known. Yeah. And so paying attention throughout the entire process about what’s happening. And it’s hard. It is hard. It’s complicated. And it’s hard, it’s complicated.
Scott Shafer: It’s complicated, people are busy, all those things. Julia, thanks so much for the call. Let’s go over now to Oakland and Valerie, you’re next. Welcome.
Caller: Hi, I’m Valerie Batchelor. I’m the vice president of Oakland Unified School Board. I’m also a candidate for running for reelection this year. And as folks already mentioned, I am really proud of the work that we’ve been able to do to keep schools open and start the school year off with 99% of our classroom teaching positions filled. But my comment is more towards how representative our school boards are around the community. I’m not the only Latina, the only immigrant, and the only queer person on our school board. And I wonder if that shows the demographic changes that we’ve seen in Oakland, because over 50% of our students are Latino. Yet only, I’m the only one representing that community in our district. And I wondered if other school districts have the same challenges around representation of their communities with their school boards.
Scott Shafer: Yeah, thanks for that question. Ashley McBride, do you want to weigh in on that?
Ashley McBride: Sure, I mean, the first thing that comes to mind for me is the pay and how we support our elected school board members. It’s something that you all brought up a little bit earlier. But I believe in Oakland Unified, it’s $3,000 a month, which actually was a raise this year before the before this year, it was around 900, I think. So that’s certainly a factor that factors into who’s able to run for the school board. You have to essentially either be able to support yourself or have another job that is pretty flexible, that allows you to take 20 to 40 additional hours a month serving on the school board. But I’m curious what the other people on the panel think.
Scott Shafer: Yeah, Molly or Ashley or Jill rather.
Jill Tucker: Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, as I said earlier, in a district like Oakland, with the local district elections within the city, within the district, the goal was to ensure that the school board members represent the demographics of the community and specifically each district. So the Oakland school board is somewhat diverse. It is not an exact representation of the demographics. But as Ashley said… It is a bit of a thankless job, and it is a tough job to do. So you have only certain people that are able to run, maybe retirees or other types of folks that have that flexibility to go to these eight-hour school board meetings and pay attention to all of these issues. But that’s the system that we have, and this is reflected in basically every district across the state.
Scott Shafer: Molly, you’re down there in the heart of Silicon Valley, where technology is ever-present and affects the economy, obviously, and so many other things. I’m wondering, like, does the conversations around things like cell phones or using iPads or anything else, AI, as that becomes bigger in education, like, how do you think the discussion is different being down there, you know, in the middle of the tech where technology really came from in a lot of ways?
Molly Gibbs: I don’t know that I would say it’s different. I would, say, you know, I’m sometimes surprised by some of the community opinion of technology given that we are in the heart of Silicon Valley. What do you mean? In terms of parents that really don’t want their kids to have access to cell phones during the classroom day or, you, know, computers or unrestricted technology access. You know, I think I was surprised when I first realized that that was a commonly shared opinion among parents in Silicon Valley.
Scott Shafer: Jill, I remember, God, it’s probably 10 years ago now. There were articles, I think, in the New York Times, maybe the Chronicle as well, about how all the people who at the top of these tech companies didn’t want their kids to have phones or iPads until a certain age because they knew how addictive they could be or distracting, you know, affecting your attention span, that kind of thing. So I guess maybe it’s not, you know, that surprising that people who know a lot about technology are a little wary of it.
Jill Tucker: Yeah, although I will say, you know, 10 years ago, there was a huge demand for technology in schools, and looking at the unequal access to technology and computers and internet access and things like that. And I think right now, you, know, but there were many parents basically not giving their kids phones, you now, depends. I think a lot of parents that maybe are working or things like want their children to have phones. Because they need to know when to pick them up when they, you know, to communicate with them. But I will say right now we’re in the middle of a huge technology backlash. And we are seeing that across the country and also in places like Silicon Valley and San Francisco. And San Francisco, which is the center of AI right now, has a grassroots effort pushing back on AI.
Scott Shafer: All right, we’re gonna have to leave it there. Jill Tucker from the San Francisco Chronicle, thanks for coming in. Thanks also to Molly Gibbs from the Mercury News and East Bay Times, and Ashley McBride from the Oakland side. Thank you all very much. Thank you. And thanks to Katie DiBenedetti as well earlier in the hour. And don’t forget to vote. You can check out the KQED Voter Guide. We’ve got some of the responses to those questionnaires and a lot more information. Thanks to all of our callers and our listeners. I’m Scott Shafer in for Alexis Madrigal. Stay tuned for another hour of Form Ahead with Mina Kim.
Announcer: Funds for the production of Forum are provided by the Jenerosity Family Fund and the members of KQED.