upper waypoint

In ‘John Proctor Is the Villain’ at ACT, the Reckonings of #MeToo Come Alive

The play, about a high school feminism club studying ‘The Crucible,’ earns its hugely popular status.
Lilla Crawford, Olivia Finkelstein, and Varinique ‘V’ Davis in the West Coast premiere of Kimberly Belflower’s ‘John Proctor Is the Villain,’ running through Dec. 13 at ACT’s Toni Rembe Theater in San Francisco. (Kevin Berne)

Mr. Smith is a delightful, youthful and devilishly handsome high school English teacher. He’s also a fan of the literary figure John Proctor, whom he calls a “great hero.” After all, the protagonist of Arthur Miller’s McCarthyism allegory, The Crucible, is deeply respected in his city of Salem for his virtuous qualities.

On the other hand, Proctor had an affair with his teenage maid Abigail Williams, then calls her a whore multiple times when she has trouble moving on from him. He whips her replacement, Mary Warren, then forces her to testify in court in support of him and his wife. He forgets one of the 10 commandments when being quizzed — the one about adultery — and wonders why his wife can’t just forgive him already for his infidelity.

Other than those minor blemishes, solid dude. 

Kaylee Kaneshiro, Olivia Finkelstein, Kyle Harris, Varinique ‘V’ Davis and Mario Houle in ‘John Proctor Is the Villain’ at ACT’s Toni Rembe Theater in San Francisco. (Kevin Berne)

In the unsubtly titled John Proctor is the Villain at ACT in San Francisco, playwright Kimberly Belflower and director Jess McLeod masterfully connect the dots between the deeply flawed Proctor and the #MeToo movement. While Smith’s young students initially accept the widely held view that Proctor was a victim of the time, and that his life ended with honor and dignity, the roaring flames of new awareness place The Crucible in a new light, upending the narrative until it combusts in the classroom.

It is 2018, a time of great promise for women. Thousands of stories of sexual assault posted to social media and reported by news outlets carry the assurance that women are finally to be believed, and horrible men brought to account.

The young girls live in a rural, Appalachian Georgia town, where distant Atlanta may as well be the moon. They have just one stoplight, with a second one planned. But they do have the internet. They also have a male teacher, Smith (Kyle Harris), who not only teaches the sex education curriculum for a whopping 10 minutes a day, but also oversees the newly formed feminism club.

Kaylee Kaneshiro, Varinique ‘V’ Davis, and Olivia Finkelstein in ‘John Proctor Is the Villain’ at ACT’s Toni Rembe Theater in San Francisco. (Kevin Berne)

The girls behave as if raised in a darkened corner, trying to ward off their prepubescent urges, no matter how desirable Harry Styles and Selena Gomez may be. They are young and ideal, full of life: overachieving teacher’s pet Beth (Olivia Finkelstein), new transfer student Nell (Varinique “V” Davis), wealthy Ivy (Stevie Allen), extra-credit seeker Mason (Ameer Ali) and the pastor’s daughter Raelynn (Kaylee Kaneshiro), who is forced to carry the stench of her father’s misdeeds.  

Raelynn has her own personal situation to deal with: her possessive boyfriend Lee (Mario Houle), who she’s been with for 7 years, beginning at age 9. Lee broke trust with Raelynn, cheating with her best friend Shelby (Lilla Crawford). For some reason, Shelby has been absent from school for months. Then she just kind of magically reappears.

Allie Pratt, Kaylee Kaneshiro, Varinique ‘V’ Davis and Olivia Finkelstein in ‘John Proctor Is the Villain’ at ACT’s Toni Rembe Theater in San Francisco. (Kevin Berne)

In short, the play is thrilling, with parallels that affirm The Crucible as a masterwork whose allegory can be applied to many moments in history.

In the case of this play, the men take turns being awful, directly connecting to Proctor himself. Lee and Raelynn share an early uncomfortable exchange, where his “rape-kissing” is, for him, a way to affirm how much he misses her, and besides, can’t she just forgive him? The only thing missing is Lee quoting Proctor by telling her to “learn charity.”

As Raelynn, Kaneshiro is a force, carrying much of the play’s weight. While Raelynn deals with her self-absorbed ex, she also harbors an embarrassment of her father, who used his pulpit for more than sermons. Ali’s Mason is hilarious, reading The Crucible out loud with droll energy in the play’s most heightened moments. As Nell, Davis is full of facial expressions that speak volumes for the audience, and a scene between Finkelstein’s Beth and Harris’ Mr. Smith is edge-of-your-seat magical.

Kaylee Kaneshiro and Lilla Crawford in ‘John Proctor Is the Villain’ at ACT’s Toni Rembe Theater in San Francisco. (Kevin Berne)

But it’s Crawford who forces a serious reckoning with Miller’s text. She plays Shelby with vicious force, a necessary disruptor who ushers everyone into a reckoning, the earth ready to rattle beneath their feet. Ultimately, the same dancing that launched witch trials that saw innocents hang is cathartic and freeing here, those guttural screams long overdue. The final group project between Shelby and Raelynn is a brilliant, cathartic topper.

Belflower has stated many times she believes The Crucible is an incredible play, and the Miller estate allowed excerpts to be quoted in her text. Hers is a play with nuance and multitudes, asking a fundamental question: Why must we calculate a woman’s actions based on men’s shitty behavior?

There once was a time when a man could sit across from a woman and promise her the moon. Unapologetically, John Proctor Is the Villain ignores that as utter nonsense, and implores women to take the moon themselves.


‘John Proctor is the Villain’ runs through Dec. 13 at the Toni Rembe Theater (415 Geary St., San Francisco). Tickets and more information here.

lower waypoint
next waypoint
Player sponsored by