The show's fans have noticed, and appreciated, Weiner's attention to musical minutiae — they have crowdsourced lists of every detectable song in every episode. One time, just before the show's fifth-season premiere, some attentive critics even got Weiner to swap a Dusty Springfield song that was anachronistic to the season's 1966 timeline by just a few months; he changed it just before the episode aired, thanking the critics and attesting to his "deep appreciation for details." (You don't say, Matt.)
Below, I've collected a bunch of the show's cleverest song choices since its 2007 premiere and, where applicable, run down some Billboard chart stats. I've stuck to original recordings (so there's no Megan Draper cooing "Zou Bisou Bisou" here, captivating as that is) and grouped them by theme, to help try to answer to question of why the music in this show is so rewarding. As critic Hanna Rosin astutely notes this week in Slate, "Weiner has a genius for making scenes that are stagey and mannered yet nonetheless emotionally affecting, by capturing the small moments." Indeed, the music of Mad Men is often the stagiest thing about the show, and yet these small musical moments, many under a minute long, consistently pay off with delight and satisfaction — even when the song is as obvious as "Satisfaction."
- Percy Faith and His Orchestra, "Theme from A Summer Place," No. 1, 1960 (Mad Men season 2, episode 5, "The New Girl")
- The Tornados, "Telstar," No. 1, 1962 (MM season 2, episode 10, "The Inheritance")
- Mr. Acker Bilk, "Stranger on the Shore," No. 1, 1962 (MM season 2, episode 13, "Meditations in an Emergency" and season 6, episode 11, "Favors")
- Herb Alpert & The Tijuana Brass, "Casino Royale," No. 27, 1967 (MM season 5, episode 13, "The Phantom")
- Paul Mauriat and His Orchestra, "Love Is Blue," No. 1, 1968 (MM season 6, episode 5, "The Flood")
Sure, the '60s had Motown, British Invasion, psychedelia — but the pop instrumental was a greater chart presence than many remember. Billboard's No. 1 song of 1960 was Percy Faith's "Theme from A Summer Place," and the aforementioned "Stranger on the Shore" was tops for 1962; both have appeared on Mad Men. Trumpeter Herb Alpert and his Tijuana Brass also make a brief appearance — they were the second-biggest album-chart act of the '60s, after the Beatles.
So while most of Mad Men's orchestral soundtrack is provided by the show's longtime composer David Carbonara, Weiner has also seeded the show with instrumentals that were the aural wallpaper of their day. In 1962 alone, three instrumentals topped Billboard's Hot 100 — the most ever in a single year — and in season two, set in '62, two of these songs make appearances: Bilk's "Stranger on the Shore," and the short-lived British band the Tornados, with their space-age ode to a communications satellite "Telstar." (Oddly, the only '62 instrumental chart-topper left untouched by Weiner is David Rose's bawdy "The Stripper.") "Telstar" is a particularly clever Easter egg, playing at the end of an episode in which adman Don Draper strong-arms his way into a West Coast aerospace conference.
Even as the show enters the politically charged late '60s, soothing instrumental hits keep on coming — Weiner juxtaposes heavy events with frilly mass culture to depict how America's Silent Majority pacified itself. In the season five finale, as Draper visits a local movie palace, Alpert's suave "Casino Royale" plays over the opening credits of the 1967 James Bond spoof of the same name; its appearance is incidental but also plays wittily off of Draper's status as the show's faux-Bond and serial bachelor. By 1968 — the year of fiery protest, national tragedy and blues-rock — French orchestra leader Paul Mauriat was atop the charts with his baroque harpsichord jam "Love Is Blue." It's the closing song of the episode dealing with the Martin Luther King Jr., assassination, the same episode that finds Don back at the movies with his son, taking in Planet of the Apes.
- Vic Damone, "On the Street Where You Live," No. 4, 1956 (MM season 1, episode 1, "Smoke Gets in Your Eyes")
- Jack Jones, "Lollipops and Roses," No. 66, 1962 (MM season 2, episode 3, "The Benefactor")
- Brenda Lee, "Break It to Me Gently," No. 4, 1962 (MM season 2, episode 7, "The Gold Violin")
- Patti Page, "Old Cape Cod" No. 3, 1957 (MM season 4, episode 3, "The Good News")
- Jim Reeves, "Welcome to My World" No. 2 Country, 1964 (MM season 4, episode 11, "Chinese Wall")
- Blood, Sweat & Tears, "You've Made Me So Very Happy," No. 2, 1969 (MM season 7, episode 5, "The Runaways")
Central to the premise of Mad Men is that it is told through the eyes of pre–Baby Boomers, for whom the 1960s' folkways and cultural uprisings come less as shocks than as irritants. The character of Don Draper was born in the 1920s, Roger Sterling in the 1910s; even young copywriter Peggy Olson's birthdate precedes America's entry into World War II. While some of the show's sharpest moments find Draper, at the cusp of his forties, confronted by rock (we'll get to that Beatles moment in a minute), Weiner also cossets Draper's generation with songs they might find appealing — and not all of them were, at that point, oldies.
Scenes involving Don's first wife Betty are often soundtracked with prerock songs, starting right with Mad Men's premiere episode: As Don returns home to the suburbs after one of his urban assignations to an unaware Betty, the show concludes with a mid-'50s hit by crooner Vic Damone, "On the Street Where You Live" (taken from a musical, My Fair Lady, that was still commanding Broadway in 1960). Or in season two, after a tense client dinner, Don and Betty drive home with the radio playing the syrupy 1962 ballad "Roses and Lollipops" — bitterly ironic as the alienated Betty weeps. And not all of these easy-listening chestnuts involve the show's older characters. In season four, as Don gently flirts with (and is rebuffed by) the niece of his California secret-keeper Anna, he dances with the young woman to a Patti Page song that was a hit when he was 30 and she perhaps 12 — reinforcing the yawning generation gap between them.
One of my favorite musical moments of the entire series came in the first half of this final season, at a party thrown by Don's second wife Megan in her new L.A. home. It's the summer of '69 — the dresses are short, the party guests stoned. And what edgy, street-fightin' record is spinning on the hi-fi? The blowsy AM-radio staple "You've Made Me So Very Happy" by Blood Sweat & Tears, a nominal "rock" song with a schmaltz core that spent much of the prior spring parked in the Billboard Top 10. It is exactly the kind of unhip song that would be playing at a party in 1969 (and exactly the kind of record no other TV show or movie set in the '60s would have put on its soundtrack). As if knowing the song isn't quite cool enough for her party, Megan pulls the record off and implores her musician friends to play.
- Bob Newhart, "Driving Instructor," No. 1 album, 1960 (MM season 1, episode 4, "New Amsterdam")
- Kyo Sakamoto, "Sukiyaki" No. 1, 1963 (MM season 2, episode 2, "Flight 1")
- The Singing Nun, "Dominique," No. 1, 1963 (MM season 3, episode 10, "The Color Blue")
- Nashville Teens, "Tobacco Road," No. 14, 1964 (MM season 4, episode 1, "Public Relations")
- Petula Clark, "I Know a Place," No. 3, 1965 (MM season 4, episode 9, "The Beautiful Girls")
- Shirley Ellis, "The Name Game," No. 3, 1964–65 (MM season 4, episode 13, "Tomorrowland")
- Jeannie C. Riley, "Harper Valley P.T.A.," No. 1, 1968 (MM season 6, episode 10, "A Tale of Two Cities")
In a season one episode, four junior Sterling Cooper admen gather in oily executive Pete Campbell's office to listen to a comedy album. Not just any album — it's The Button-Down Mind of Bob Newhart, 1960's top-selling LP and the first comedy disc to win the Grammy for Album of the Year (a feat repeated only one more time by a comedy disc, Vaughn Meader's Kennedy-spoofing The First Family). Here again is a side of the '60s that Weiner unearths and celebrates — the curiosities, the detritus, the cheese, some of it surprisingly enduring. It takes a puckish sense of humor to feature a song by peppy British hitmaker Petula Clark, and then choose not her enduring smash "Downtown" but rather its soundalike followup hit, "I Know a Place."
Many of these quirky hits are strategically placed for period-accurate ambience — and gentle commentary. When Don arrives at the apartment of his season three mistress, schoolteacher Suzanne Farrell, spinning on her turntable is the late-'63 French-language smash "Dominique" by the Singing Nun — a perfect encapsulation, for Don, of her alluring innocence. In season four, Shirley Ellis's tongue-twisting, banana-fanna-fo-fanning hit "The Name Game" plays on the jukebox of a diner where Don brings his kids. In season six, when the too-old-to-be-hip Sterling Cooper men visit L.A. and attend a house party filled with poseurs and hangers-on, in the background is Jeannie C. Riley's sassy, poseur-destroying 1968 chart-topper "Harper Valley P.T.A."
TV bloggers did catch one apparent anachronism in the episode that features Kyo Sakamoto's smash "Sukiyaki." This mistitled, oft-covered hit became the only all-Japanese song to top the U.S. charts in 1963. However, it appears in Mad Men's season two premiere, set in the spring of 1962. Leave it to detail-oriented Weiner to find an escape hatch: The song was in fact first released in Japan in 1961, under its original title "Ue o Muite Arukō," and in the episode, it's playing as Don breaks up with a client at ... a Japanese restaurant, one that could maybe, plausibly have had the record in its original pressing. As the Singing Nun might say, touché.
- Peter, Paul & Mary, "Early in the Morning," No. 1 album, 1962 (MM season 2, episode 8, "A Night to Remember")
- Bob Dylan, "Don't Think Twice, Its All Right," 1963 (MM season 1, episode 13, "The Wheel")
- Roy Orbison, "Shahdaroba," 1963 (MM season 3, episode 13, "Shut the Door. Have a Seat.")
- Simon & Garfunkel, "Bleecker Street," 1964 (MM season 4, episode 7, "The Suitcase")
- The Crystals, "He Hit Me (It Felt Like a Kiss)," 1962 (MM season 5, episode 4, "Mystery Date")
- The Beach Boys, "I Just Wasn't Made For These Times" 1966 (MM season 5, episode 6, "Far Away Places")
- The Beatles, "Tomorrow Never Knows," 1966 (MM season 5, episode 8, "Lady Lazarus")
- Nancy Sinatra, "You Only Live Twice," No. 44, 1967 (MM season 5, episode 13, "The Phantom")
- Serge Gainsbourg & Brigitte Bardot, "Bonnie and Clyde," 1968 (MM season 6, episode 4, "To Have and to Hold")
- The Monkees, "Porpoise Song (Theme from Head)," No. 62, 1968 (MM season 6, episode 12, "The Quality of Mercy")
- The Zombies, "This Will Be Our Year," 1968 (MM season 7, episode 2, "A Day's Work")
It would be nuts for Weiner to avoid totemic '60s artists fully. Generally, when he has decided to invoke the decade's folkie bards and pop eminences, he makes his song choices count — at least half the time, he chooses non-hits, invoking everyone from Roy Orbison to The Zombies without the accompanying duh moment.
Peter, Paul and Mary's 1962 debut album was a huge seller, but Mad Men avoids its campfire hits ("If I Had a Hammer," "Lemon Tree") for the more definitive opener "Early in the Morning." Speaking of PPM, they had the hit with "Don't Think Twice, It's All Right," not Dylan, but it's Bob's version that closes the show's first season, very memorably. Hall of Fame producer Phil Spector is represented not by the Ronettes' "Be My Baby" or the Righteous Brothers' "You've Lost That Lovin' Feeling" but rather the controversial, radio-banned and brutally ironic Crystals single "He Hit Me (It Felt Like a Kiss)." The Beach Boys and the Monkees, each band a prolific hitmaker, are represented by two of their trippiest non-hits. And since "You Only Live Twice" was actually one of Nancy Sinatra's smaller '60s hits, the song may now be more associated with Don Draper — how great was that season five finale montage? — than James Bond.
As for the Fab Four, Weiner telegraphed the Beatles' influence on the show (Don buying his daughter Sally's affection with tickets to their 1965 Shea Stadium gig) long before he had the budget to license their music. When he finally did in 2012, he went with an especially heady Lennon cut — "Tomorrow Never Knows," the closing track on the quite literally pivotal album Revolver — and has an exasperated, unimpressed Draper lift the needle off the record before the song even finishes. NPR's own Ann Powers questioned Weiner's use of the song, and whether it would ever have alienated a savvy ad man like Don. But let's pause and admire Weiner's chutzpah one more time: You have one quarter-million-dollar budget to devote to licensing one Beatles song — the very act is guaranteed media attention — and you choose one of their thorniest and least radio-friendly (albeit one of their greatest)? Talk about meta: Weiner's "Tomorrow Never Knows" scene was his own tobacco letter, an advertisement for its own daring that became more about the show's influence than about the show's content. If it wasn't one of Mad Men's best musical moments, it was perhaps the show's most savvy — Don Draper himself could have dreamed it up.
- Chubby Checker, "The Twist," No. 1, 1960 and No. 1, 1962 (MM season 1, episode 8, "The Hobo Code")
- The Rolling Stones, "(I Can't Get No) Satisfaction," No. 1, 1965 (MM season 4, episode 8, "The Summer Man")
- Sonny & Cher, "I Got You Babe," No. 1, 1965 (MM season 4, episode 13, "Tomorrowland")
- Dusty Springfield, "You Don't Have to Say You Love Me," No. 4, 1966 (MM season 5, episode 1–2, "A Little Kiss")
- The Kinks, "You Really Got Me," No. 7, 1964 (MM season 5, episode 11, "The Other Woman")
- Big Brother and the Holding Company, "Piece of My Heart," No. 12, 1968 (MM season 6, episode 10, "A Tale of Two Cities")
- Judy Collins, "Both Sides Now" No. 8, 1968 (MM season 6, episode 13, "In Care Of")
- The Spencer Davis Group, "I'm a Man," No. 10, 1967 (MM season 7, episode 1, "Time Zones")
- Waylon Jennings, "Only Daddy That'll Walk the Line," No. 2 Country, 1968 (MM season 7, episode 5, "The Runaways")
- Frank Sinatra, "My Way," No. 27, 1969 (MM season 7, episode 6, "The Strategy")
- Peggy Lee, "Is That All There Is?" No. 11, 1969 (MM season 7, episode 8, "Severance")
Here's the other half of the "totemic" category — the dozen or so of times Mad Men has gone straight for the jugular, choosing songs that were not only huge hits but still clearly read as '60s iconography. One of the very best came early: flirty Peggy Olson sidling up to bitch-faced Pete Campbell to the strains of the 1960 über-smash "The Twist." Super-obvious, right? But for those of us with Billboard mojo, it's a clever moment — Chubby Checker's smash hit No. 1 twice (the only Hot 100 hit ever to do so), catching on first with teenagers before finding a toehold with club-going adults and topping the chart all over again. Peggy, Mad Men's ultimate liminal character, is a one-woman representation of both audiences, twisting her arrival into self-assured adulthood. No wonder the petty, controlling Pete doesn't want to dance with her.
"The Twist" is a rare early–Mad Men example of a signpost hit. Most of these expensive-to-license smashes appeared after season four, suggesting Weiner was more hamstrung by his fledgling show's budget early on than by any deliberate artistic choice. But even over the last few seasons, Weiner has spent his newfound clout on coveted songs just infrequently enough to make their appearance feel indelible rather than inevitable. If you've watched the show devotedly, I barely need to detail these killer scenes: Don "Summer Man" Draper roaming the streets to the Stones' "Satisfaction"; Peggy ditching Sterling Cooper with a sassy smirk to the Kinks' "You Really Got Me"; Pete toking up to the liberating yowl of Janis's "Piece of My Heart"; Megan picking up Don at LAX in a convertible as Steve Winwood bleats Spencer Davis's "I'm a Man"; Don and Peggy slow-dancing to Frank's definitive "My Way."
Most of these songs are not used diegetically — "My Way" is playing on an on-screen radio, but otherwise it's debatable whether, say, Peggy is thinking about the Kinks at her moment of freedom. But the fact that these songs were all big hits is essential to these scenes — they define the background of the characters' lives. If Sunday's first episode of season 7.2 is any indication, Weiner plans to keep deploying iconic tunes on his way to the exit. Peggy Lee's immortal late-1969 single "Is That All There Is?" bookended the episode, an inevitable, none-too-subtle evocation of the exhaustion of the '60s and the protagonists' emotional voids, even after getting everything they thought they wanted.
For me, though, none of these moments tops the most moving use of music in Mad Men's history, the finale of season six. Don has just been released by Sterling Cooper for self-immolating during a Hershey pitch, picking the worst possible moment to reveal his unhappy childhood and fraudulent biography to a key client. It's Thanksgiving Day 1968, and Don picks up his kids — but before driving them to dinner, the confessional and newly unfettered Don brings them to a derelict, abandoned Victorian house now surrounded by projects: the seedy brothel from his childhood. "This," Don tells the kids, "is where I grew up" — and up pops Judy Collins's achingly beautiful cover of Joni Mitchell's "Both Sides Now," its lyrics a dreamy fantasia pierced with self-lacerating regret (a Mitchell trademark). It's the dialogue in Don's head, in song.