Camille Rose Garcia: Tragic Kingdom
As a fan of Camille Rose Garcia, I was ready to simply bask in the beautiful gloom of her strange world. I've seen a good amount of her work before and never once gleaned a specific context for her lovely doom beyond the obvious visual references to old cartoons and hipster fashion. Garcia weaves so much intricacy into her paintings that I have never craved a specific meaning, delighting in the vagueness of her surreal dreamscapes, twisted creatures and, well, masterfully pretty pictures.
But Tragic Kingdom: The Art of Camille Rose Garcia at the San Jose Museum of Art reveals that there is a lot more behind Garcia's work, or at least that she fervently intends there to be. As narrated by the artist, nearly all of the pieces began with Garcia stumbling across some horrific current event -- the Iraq war, Hurricane Katrina -- and using it to spin elaborate doomsday scenarios inspired by our "collective destructive death spiral."
The series Retreat Syndrome, titled from the Philip K. Dick story, laments the environment of fear after September 11th, and scorns how "everyone" hid in denial, smugly characterized by "anti-depressants and 500 thread-count sheets." The complex and dire imagery of suicidal, vomiting princesses in the Ultraviolenceland series, named from A Clockwork Orange, is chalked up to Garcia's being "tired of the general state of things in America." The Soft Machine references William S. Burroughs' criticism of political complacency, and paints capitalism as a kind of enabling and sinister pet/master -- "the evil empire using more subversive tactics to enslave people." There's even the predictable scenario of ignorant consumers blindly gorging themselves on a yummy new sweet that -- surprise! -- is actually made of dissidents executed by the government, their remains given to a sinister tycoon, Mr. Peppermint, to turn a profit.
One series, Doomcave Daydreams, features bright purple butterflies meant to "search for beauty and hope in a doomed world," but against what Garcia calls "a sea of extinctual doom," these images don't feel like a relief. Each description took the same exaggerated, end-of-the-world (literally) tone, making it difficult to take Garcia's moral outrage du jour seriously (especially when the topics change -- war, capitalism, environmental damage, the pharmaceutical industry, inhumane farming practices -- but the imagery and the artist's strident pitch remain the same from painting to painting). Evil duck creatures tote dark bottles of poison. Leering goblins menace in stripey suits. Dripping black poison threatens elegant swans, fawns, and pretty girls in retro clothes. Day-glo sea creatures languish in toxic waters. Blood smears canvases and animals. I get it; things are bad.
I found the show's tone of resigned epic tragedy exhausting. The lack of nuance feels like a distracting flaw in Garcia's work. Rather than encouraging discussion, Garcia seems to luxuriate in the maudlin hopelessness of it all. This kind of static portrait of corruption adds up to fear mongering or, worse yet, hints of forfeit on the side of the counterculture -- if the world is rotten and doomed, why try and save it?
There is also a grating sense of self righteousness to the exhibition. Garcia grew up in suburban Los Angeles, right in the happy, happy, oh so happy shadow of Disneyland, and its philosophy that good is defined by the absence of bad (or literally, the absence of garbage, delivery trucks, or any breaks in "magic," a.k.a. reality) -- a way of dealing with bumps in the road by not tolerating their existence. I couldn't help but think that this culture is partly responsible for Garcia's indignation as someone who once, perhaps, bought into that happiness myth.
In reality, good and terrible things exist side by side, and the perception of which is "winning" is often based on the sheer will to see it one way or the other. Garcia's insistent pessimism ends up feeling as brittle and precious as the fairytale optimism she rebels against.
There's a place for emotional calls to arms, and a kind of punk rock rattling of cages to jar people out of complacency. But Garcia makes no mention of the reality of her topics beyond that they are terrible, which just seems like a shallow response to something as complex as entire economic systems (like what would she prefer?) or the Iraq War. And using politics to manipulate emotions seems suspect to me, in general. She should give her audience more credit for being informed enough to want more to chew on than blanket pronouncements about complex issues and references to writers as firmly established in the counterculture as the "Happy Meal" is in the mainstream.
I have great respect for Garcia's artistry, and the enormous energy she has put into developing such a distinct style. Her work is breathtaking to see in person. I can't think of a recent show that visually excited me more. Garcia makes expert use of pleasing My Little Pony colors to render her "darkness" as unbelievably cute. Her elegant, sad-eyed cartoon humans and animals languish over layers of lush colors and patterns. Each fantasy scene of subterranean escape or violent chaos feels visually complete. Even the tears her characters shed are delicately designed cascades of drops and arcs.
It's disappointing to find out that the impetus for these works isn't nearly as skillful as the work itself. I'm not quite sure what we can reasonably expect from our artists, who have to juggle making something meaningful AND aesthetically stimulating. Does beautiful work have to be meaningful? No. Does meaningful work have to be beautiful? No. But when art sets out to tackle difficult issues -- with a clear desire to instigate -- it should attempt to be as thoughtful as its subjects are complex.
Tragic Kingdom: The Art of Camille Rose Garcia runs through September 23rd at the San Jose Museum of Art.
More on Visual Arts
NPR Film | Dec 06, 2013
The documentary follows the life, career and recent re-emergence of musician and riot grrrl, Kathleen Hanna, from her beginnings with Bikini Kill to her latest venture, The Julie Ruin. By Ella Taylor
NPR Film | Dec 06, 2013
Bettie Page Reveals All explores the life and lasting legacy of the 1950s pinup queen. The documentary features interviews from Page's friends, fans, lovers — and the sensation herself, interviewed just before her death. By Ella Taylor
The Do List | Dec 05, 2013
Cy Musiker and Peter Hartlaub scout the Bay Area for things to do this coming weekend and turn up winter follies, some cow-punk, and much more!
Theater Review | Dec 05, 2013
British two-man parody whizzes through the wizard world of Harry Potter. By Sam Hurwitt
The Bay Bridged | Dec 04, 2013
Listen to The Bay Bridged mix of bands playing the Bay Area in December 2013, including: King Krule, Blood Sister, The Herms, Sun Araw, Holy Ghost!, and more.
Art & Design
Food as a symbol of politics, diet, gender roles, technology, isolation, gluttony and blatant commercialism has been with us for ages and in many forms. A massive exhibit explores how American artists, from Pilgrim times to Andy Warhol, used paintings of food to shape and reflect our national identity.
New York City is home to more paintings by Johannes Vermeer — eight — than any other city. And until mid-January, it's playing host to one more: the world-renowned Girl with a Pearl Earring. Critic Lloyd Schwartz says, since the painting's 1994 restoration, "It's even more breathtaking than I remembered."
The sale of the famous painting of a woman and boy bowing their heads in prayer at a table in a bustling restaurant set a record for Rockwell's art.
The Perez Art Museum Miami opens this week, and despite praise for the building's design, the museum faces controversy over its name and has an uphill battle in a city where the art scene is already defined by private collectors.
Also on KQED.org this week ...
Obamacare Explained: A Guide for Californians
Starting Jan 1, 2014, most Americans will be required to have health insurance or pay a fine. KQED has created a simple guide to explain how the health law affects you, your family or your small business.
KQED Celebrates the Holidays
Find holiday-related KQED television and radio programming, events, gift ideas, recipes, and other Web-exclusive goodies.